I disagree with the thought that he isn’t elite. While his SB run was impressive the defense was a huge part of that run. If Josh got defensive play like that in any of our playoff runs he would have seen a Super Bowl by now.
I think Joe Burrow is firmly planted as the #4 QB in the league. Josh, Pat, and Lamar are a step above him imho. Lately it’s been said that they are the big 4. I think it’s the big 3, and then Burrow on a tier slightly below.
The best ability is availability and you can’t count on him being healthy.