Jump to content

Guedarian? or Rommel?  

7 members have voted

  1. 1. Guedarian? or Rommel?

    • Rommel
      1
    • Gudarian
      6


Recommended Posts

Posted
  Ghost of BiB said:
You're having a French moment again. BTW, can you decipher Bills last on Korea?

I thought he only saw Star Wars once. Did he like it? Or was he always hung on Yoda? (one of those understanding eye to eye things)

371514[/snapback]

 

Basically, he's saying that MacArthur was a crappy general because he advanced to the Yalu...fundamentally sound, though I'm not quite sure how he got "started" the Korean War from that (apparently Inchon was only practice before the real war started).

 

I don't think it had a thing to do with Star Wars, since that's a bad movie. Or good. Or at least he liked it. Or something. :P

  • Replies 41
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Top Posters In This Topic

Posted
  Crap Throwing Monkey said:
Basically, he's saying that MacArthur was a crappy general because he advanced to the Yalu...fundamentally sound, though I'm not quite sure how he got "started" the Korean War from that (apparently Inchon was only practice before the real war started). 

 

I don't think it had a thing to do with Star Wars, since that's a bad movie.  Or good.  Or at least he liked it.  Or something.  :P

371523[/snapback]

 

I'm incapable now. I'm still laughing on the recipe. BF finally put me over the edge.

Posted
  Ghost of BiB said:
I'm incapable now. I'm still laughing on the recipe. BF finally put me over the edge.

371543[/snapback]

 

Judging by the photos, he must be a master chef.

Posted
  detoxsmurf said:
Judging by the photos, he must be a master chef.

371552[/snapback]

 

Hey, when you eat 16 oz. of pasta fried in a quarter-cup of butter and 3-4 eggs, marinated in pickle juice, you start to pack on the pounds.

 

And let's face it...if you're non-discriminating enough to eat THAT, you'll pretty much eat anything, which doesn't exactly promote a healthy weight...

Posted
  Crap Throwing Monkey said:
Hey, when you eat 16 oz. of pasta fried in a quarter-cup of butter and 3-4 eggs, marinated in pickle juice, you start to pack on the pounds.

 

And let's face it...if you're non-discriminating enough to eat THAT, you'll pretty much eat anything, which doesn't exactly promote a healthy weight...

371558[/snapback]

 

I wish TracyLee was here, so that she could verify that all those ingredients can be bought with food stamps.

Posted
  detoxsmurf said:
I wish TracyLee was here, so that she could verify that all those ingredients can be bought with food stamps.

371572[/snapback]

:P:D

Posted
  EC-Bills said:
:P  You're talking about BF.  For some reason I was being tardo and thinking you guys were talking about VA :D

371584[/snapback]

Oh, he's gonna live that down ever. If you are ever being stalked by a lawn gnome, think back to this post.

Posted
  Alaska Darin said:
Oh, he's gonna live that down ever.  If you are ever being stalked by a lawn gnome, think back to this post.

371614[/snapback]

:doh::lol:

 

He better be careful then that I don't don't accidently overlook him and run him over with my riding mower :lol:

Posted
  Ghost of BiB said:
I'm sure someone will say "Rommel...I've heard of him!"

371444[/snapback]

 

 

I've heard of Gudarian. They do my health insurance. DING!

Posted
  VABills said:
This was from a guy whose services best Generals were a nutcase who started the Korean War because he didn't follow orders and stop, and the Supreme Commander who later became president even though he finished last in his class at West Point.  You expect him to know what a good general is?

371497[/snapback]

You forgetting Black Jack? He did OK....

Posted
  Crap Throwing Monkey said:
Hell, VA's nuts just for calling Dugout Doug a "great" general.  :lol:

375651[/snapback]

No, I said those in that service called him a great general. They also refer to Mister barely passed Eisenhower as a great one also.

 

The USMC will always have Chesty Puller.

Posted
  Alaska Darin said:
Which truly sounds like a porn star.

375668[/snapback]

You know he maybe dead. But I dare you to go to his grave and say that. He would probably come to life and rip your heart out.

Posted
  VABills said:
No, I said those in that service called him a great general.  They also refer to Mister barely passed Eisenhower as a great one also. 

 

True enough...and even then, not many in the Army thing MacArthur was all that great anymore.

 

Ike, though...so he barely passed West Point. So what? West Point makes officers, but it doesn't determine their success. And like it or not, Ike was the perfect general for the job he was given.

 

On a side note...did you know Nimitz was almost released from the service early on in his career for putting his destroyer aground? One's record at West Point, or even as a junior officer, does not determine the quality of one's generalship.

 

  Quote
The USMC will always have Chesty Puller.

375662[/snapback]

 

Darin's right. It does sound like a porn name.

 

And somehow, I think Chesty would appreciate that observation even as he was stomping my head into the ground for making it. :lol:

Posted
  /dev/null said:
Since before your sun burned hot in space, and before your race was born, I have awaited a question...

 

oh wait, that was Guardian :lol:

372276[/snapback]

 

you kirk phreaks disappoint me, not one had anything to say about this...

×
×
  • Create New...