I think Eli is vastly overrated myself. His accuracy sucks, his consistency sucks, and I think he'd look even more lost than he does already at times without Burress. And yes, the name "Manning" helps the perception of him too. But even I have to admit he has a knack of executing clutch drives in the 4th Qtr, which JP hasn't shown yet. I think that the discrepancy in supporting casts is overestimated by this board, as the Giants OL is nothing special, nor is the depth in their WR core; they just have that extra weapon at TE.