[Year in Review - My grades]

I think this is spot on except Edmunds. I don't think he can play DE like Clowney as that is an elite talent to get to the QB that can't be merely acquired by switching positions. That would take gaining wait, and see if he has enough burst to play the position. 

 

Otherwise I agree with 99% of this. I would give Frazier and McDermott a slightly higher score only because they produced wins from defense. I don't think McDermott would have had the same season record wise if we had the same schedule as the Lions. We wouldn't have their W/L record, but I agree it would have been an 8-8 season with that schedule. 

 

Ultimately I put a lot more blame on Daboll and give him a D grade because it's obvious Josh Allen doesn't read the field quick enough for complex routes that take a while to open up. 

[2019 Re-Draft: Cody Ford vs DK Metcalf]

I would still take Ford on this offense and this quarterback. Ford needs to be moved to guard and he'll be a good player for a long time. He's not a tackle at the NFL level, but he'll make a great guard. If I had to choose between a great guard or a so-so WR with a great QB I'll take the guard.