Jump to content

Buffalo86

Community Member
  • Posts

    1,115
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by Buffalo86

  1. On 5/9/2020 at 9:24 PM, NewEra said:

    You wouldn’t happen to be an anti whaley guy would you?

     

    Anti-losing, which means anti-Whaley, anti-Nix, anti-Levy (as GM), and especially anti-Brandon.  However, I don't think I needed to be anti-Whaley to disagree with your post.  I'm not blasting him for the pick.  He took a shot in the 5th round, but it didn't work out due to the very concerns (weight & character) that caused Karlos to fall to that spot in the draft.  IMO, it's not worthy of criticism or praise.

     

    Imagine this was a "Should we give Kelvin Benjamin another shot?" thread and I wrote "Was a damn good trade I must say by Beane. Benjamin has no one to blame but himself."  Would you agree with that?  If not, should I just chalk it up to you being an anti-Beane guy?

     

     

  2. 17 hours ago, Bferra13 said:

    Was a dam good draft pick I must say by Whaley. Guy has no one to blame but himself. Hes most likely toast by now after being out of the league and professional conditioning programs so long.

     

    Whaley drafted a guy with weight & character concerns who proceeded to eat & smoke his way out of the league in 1 year.  I don't fault Whaley for taking a shot on a boom or bust prospect in the 5th, but I don't see how it could be considered a good pick beyond 2015.

  3. 28 minutes ago, Freddie's Dead said:

     

    Except he didn't play for a whole year.  Yes, he had two 1000-yard seasons before he ran himself out of town.  But he never had any fire or guts.  Didn't even know it was 4th down in NE, one of the many games we had them beat and let them off the hook.  He was a POS.

     

    My bad.  I mistakenly thought you were letting personal feelings about McGahee cloud your memory of his career.

    • Thank you (+1) 1
  4. 9 hours ago, Freddie's Dead said:

     

    *****in' A Bubba, FredEx all day.  Willis "It was 4th down?" McGahee has no business on this list.  If not for Maybin, the worst 1st round pick in Bills history.

     

    I'd say he was a better first-round pick than Mike Williams, Erik Flowers, JP Losman, John McCargo, Donte Whitner, Leodis McKelvin, CJ Spiller, EJ Manuel, and Sammy Watkins.  I know we're supposed to hate McGahee because he ripped on Applebee's, but let's be fair:  he won Comeback Player of the Year in '04 & was a borderline stud for the 3 years we got out of him.  You can say we didn't need him because we had Travis Henry, but it's possible that OBD had misgivings about giving a new contract to a guy who had 11 kids with 10 women & would later serve time for running a cocaine ring.  

     

  5. 22 hours ago, MJS said:

    Bills vs Jets shouldn't be that big of a contest. Their best QB is a guy who threw more interceptions than TD's and lost more games than he won.

    Vick is like the best player in Madden history, but are they basing it on Madden ratings and not real life? How do they include guys from before Madden was a thing?

     

    Madden has been including all-time players/teams for decades.  I doubt their ratings on Dick Butkus and Deacon Jones have changed very much over time.  

    Also, I vote Henry Jones for Bills' starting SS.

    • Like (+1) 1
  6. 53 minutes ago, Buffalo_Stampede said:

    Why would he take that here?

     

    He took it in GB.  Beane was Assistant GM when the Panthers drafted Funchess; McDermott was DC.  Generally speaking, former Panthers who have crossed paths with those guys don't seem to be opposed to coming to Buffalo.  Also, I don't think being a GB WR not named Davante Adams is such a desirable job.  

     

    38 minutes ago, John from Riverside said:

    Isn’t funchess just not very good

     

    Probably not.  He looked like he was on the rise in year 3, but has been injured & inconsistent in the 2 years since.  As a big bodied WR, it's debatable that he'd be any better than Duke.  I'm not saying I wanted him, but it wouldn't have been a terrible signing for the price.

    • Like (+1) 1
  7. 48 minutes ago, ColoradoBills said:

    Well with the EJ Gaines signing that just removed CB as a "need" in the draft.

    Is it maybe time for Beane to look for Josh Allen's long term backup in the draft?

     

    Would a 4th round pick get us that?  What say the college fans, if so who could that guy be.

     

    I don't believe signing EJ makes us any more set at CB than we were before, but we're set up nicely for BPA.

    • Like (+1) 2
  8. 9 hours ago, MTLBills said:

    I don’t understand why everyone, including experts, are mocking RB to the Bills so early? Singletary had a great first year. I understand the need of rb but don’t see why they use an early pick (2 or 3) on one. I think it’s more likely to see one selected in the 5th and beyond. 
     

    I think it’s pretty obvious it will be a corner at 54. 

     

    8 hours ago, inaugural balls said:

     

    Bills will select BPA. It might be a RB.

     

    Exactly.  Just like last year, OBD has done a good job of filling their holes in FA, setting themselves up for BPA.  By the way, it still feels weird to say "Just like last year, OBD..." and have it be something good.  Nevertheless, here's hoping that BPA aligns as perfectly with our needs as last year.  

     

    As for "why RB?":  1) we're a run-first team 2) Singletary missed a quarter of last season to injury 3) Frank Gore just vacated 180 touches out of the backfield

    • Like (+1) 1
  9. 2 hours ago, DCOrange said:

    I definitely would not trade up for a WR after getting Diggs. If Mims is there at 54, I’d be happy to take him there

     

    Agreed.  We're strong enough at WR that it wouldn't make much sense to trade up, barring unforeseen circumstances like Jeudy or Lamb falling out of the 1st.  Some of our favorite WR prospects will fall to the later rounds; it happens every spring.

     

  10. Mitch Goldich of SI had this to say about Newton:

     

    So if he’s not walking into an open starting job, here’s my total darkhorse candidate that should consider him: The Buffalo Bills.

     

    The Bills are a playoff team. They have a great defense. They came into this offseason with a ton of cap room, and still have the 10th-most available. They just brought in a legitimate No. 1 wide receiver. They also may smell a particularly ripe time to go all-in chasing their first AFC East title since 1995, with the Dolphins still building up, the Jets being eternally unreliable and the Patriots finally turning the page on the Tom Brady era.

     

    I know Josh Allen has a lot of supporters insisting he got better throughout last season, and that he has a chance to take another step forward this year. I also know how the nation felt during his most recent game, watching him struggle his way through the second half and overtime of a 16-point blown lead against the Texans.

     

    The Bills might come to the conclusion that Josh Allen is good enough. They could also easily be one year away from the situation Chicago found itself in with Mitchell Trubisky this offseason—suddenly very aware their quarterback simply isn’t the guy, in danger of letting the window close on an otherwise good team. Buffalo would be better served taking a chance on an undervalued player one year early instead of overpaying for a solution one year too late. If Newton is healthy, he could be an immediate upgrade over Allen and make Buffalo a real contender in the AFC. If he’s not healthy, Buffalo would still have the quarterback that led the team to a wild-card berth last year.

     

    Bills head coach Sean McDermott was the defensive coordinator in Carolina for six years, including Cam’s MVP/Super Bowl campaign. Of course, that’s not the same as Philip Rivers walking into his old offensive coordinator Frank Reich’s system in Indy. But they are at least familiar with each other. McDermott is uniquely qualified to know whether or not Newton would be a good fit for that team, outside the X’s and O’s of the scheme. If Newton is going to be available for below-market value, somebody should pounce. Why not Buffalo?

     

    https://www.si.com/nfl/2020/03/22/offseason-story-lines-tom-brady-cam-newton-coronavirus

    • Haha (+1) 1
  11. 1 minute ago, Mat68 said:

    Even though he blew up the combine I think there is strong chance at Taylor being available at 54.  With the  incredible amount of usage at Wisconsin I think that will scare teams away.  At 54 im ok with him because he will share the load with Singletary and he is on a reasonable rookie deal.  He is the most produuctive and most athletic running back in the class.  I think Buffalo runs to the podium and may even trade up for him in rd 2.

     

    I can't see Taylor falling to us, but I'd be all for it.  He's a threat to take it to the house every time & never missed a game.  I'm not concerned about the heavy usage.  If you're re-signing your RB after his rookie contract runs out, you're probably doing it wrong. 

  12. Having given this a great deal of thought, I agree with others that Hyde seems like the perfect complement to Singletary.  Spotrac lists his market value as $3M/year.  If that's even close to accurate, I'd sign him in a heartbeat.  This would not stop me from drafting another RB if there was good value to be had.

    • Like (+1) 2
×
×
  • Create New...