First of all nice edit: The OC has an influence on the play that is called, not the execution of the play. Sometimes it is the play call and sometimes it is the execution. If for one minute you think that a rookie QB should be throwing that pass in that situation, you should not be involved in this discussion.
On way too many good play call situations JP made poor execution, end of story, that is the reason he is the backup. Just by using the word "trentites" shows your bag lickin love for JP (of course he should still be the starter). The best QB for the job is starting get over it.