FireChan

There are cases not directly attributed to the psychiatric condition "gender dysphoria?" Have you told the DSM-V that not everyone with Borderline personality disorder had a personality disorder?

Oh yeah, Carr ain't a HoFer but he's close to if not at franchise level.

A stop gap QB for peanuts? Yeah, that's a good find. TT may have been the second best FA QB this decade.

Phillip Rivers ain't a franchise QB? What?

I think we should make all roster decisions based on this criteria. I don't see a single Bill who is make or breaking a Super Bowl run on this roster. Let's trade them all for 5th and 6th round picks.

Well that's because you have your facts wrong, per usual. He had a 4 year deal with 2 years left. With only 2 years left in his contract and his opt out clause, he wanted more security than what amounted to 1 year on the hook. And it was widely reported that Marrone was negotiating extensions for him and his staff. Pegulas were open to extending him, but not the staff. I guess if you're not above disregarding wins, you can just disregard reports that you disagree with. Stay on message, my dude.

Ask them. They offered it.

The salary cap and roster limit had no effect on keeping Gillislee. But you knew that. Gillislee was on the team with Karlos. How was he his replacement? We replaced Karlos with JWill. And that worked to great success. Moot.

You could make this argument about 46 Bills. But all those cuts add up. When Boom Herron was on the field, they "knew we were running?" What? We didn't replace Karlos. We still have not. We have a team where the #2 RB probably has the most importance among the league. That's not an ounce of hyperbole. Calling it just a "backup" is not fair. The Bills are a better team in 2016 with MG as our #2 RB. Period.

Every JAG? No. Mike G? Yes. I would've looked at the tandem of Mike G and Shady and how well they both played and tried to keep a strength of this team together. I wouldn't risk losing a good player over pennies and creating yet another hole on a team with too many. But hey, that makes too much sense. Bills gonna Bills.

Gillislee was a nobody, but he may be the next Arian Foster, who quickly became an non-journeyman. Karlos was a talented player with huge character red flags who still got drafted. I don't think it's the same as "two bums." IMO.

When he got on the field, he sucked. If he was #2 on the depth chart, how does that make him not suck?

They were both talented. CC Reggie Bush CC Jonathan Williams CC Boom Herron CC Boobie Dixon CC Cierre Wood All those guys had such great success!

Like I said, a lame appeal to authority. No one has to have done something before for it to be a good idea. Diuretics aren't prescribed because "everyone does it." They are prescribed because it's a good idea and they work. You know all this.

Except the Pegulas who offered an extension due to the miracle.

This is an actual argument. Sadly, it's on the wrong point. At least you know the difference.

Teams also don't draft enough QB's. NFL teams, by and large, are stupid. Your appeal to their "wisdom" is laughable.

And yet, we were above .500.

Exactly. Gotta try to take W's away because you don't like the coach.

No. I'm not. You're supposed to argue the principle. But you can't. So you're making these wacky pseudoarguments.

I'm sorry we have resorted to pretending W's didn't happen to make ourselves feel better. Must be tough.

Again, these are not arguments. These are you saying it wouldn't happen. Which means nothing. MG should have received the second round tender. It made little sense to risk losing him for virtually no reward. Refute that argument instead of saying nothing.

You can shout this until you're blue in the face, but it isn't an argument. Signing MG and Hogan to the higher round tender would've ensured we kept them for peanuts, $700k and $1M extra for one season. Instead we lost them for nothing, and a 5th rounder. When the whole point of tendering a player is to keep them.

Well, really just Brady and a select few. If the game meant something to the Bills, do you think they wouldn't have rested Brady?

Signing both players with the higher tender was clearly the smarter choice.