One thing to remember, the defense in Denver was absolutly terrible. I live out in Colorado and listen to a lot of sports talk radio on my commute and of course there is a lot of discussion in regards to this. A lot of arguments swirl about the fact he hasn't taken his teams to the playoffs, etc. Some stats about Cutler jumped out at me, when the defense gives up less than 30 points he has won 2/3 of his games, when his defenses allow more than 30 he still has a better winnng percentage than a lot of other qb's (one example is eli was 1-16 or something like that in his games where that occured). Last year when the d allowed 30 or less Denver was 5-2, over 30 3-6. From what I've seen he has all the tools to be successful. If you told me to take my pick between Cutler or TE, I'd take Culter. However, I hope to be proven wrong.
Just looked up 2007 games in when the d gave up 30 or less Denver's record was 7-3. Last 2 yrs his record is 12-5 when the d gives up less than 30 points.