Jump to content

Who was a bigger hitter? Clements or Winfield?


Recommended Posts

  • Replies 44
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Top Posters In This Topic

It's tough seeing players like this walk. I would have to say Nate was a bigger hitter, but it's pretty close to call. It was fun watching Winfield because he was so small.

 

Another question - was Nate the most naturally athletic player ever in a bills uniform?

Uhmmm..Id have to put OJ,Bruce,Cookie,Robert James above him while putting him at the same level as Jerry Butler,Eric Moulds,..and that receiver we had...uhmmmm.....uhhhhhhhh.......ahmad rashad.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Winfield never missed a tackle nor made other critical mistakes. Every so often, Nate would make the huge mistake. A few years ago, he was a big part of why we lost the opener to J'Ville on the last play. That same year, he fumbled a punt against he Steelers in a game we had to have to make the playoffs. I'd go with Winfield.

 

We have had lots of great athletes here. Jerry Butler for one. OJ. Bruce Smith. For a lineman, McKenzie was a great athlete as well. You have to put Lofton on that list. Corneilius Bennett. Nate is a good athlete but I never saw him as some sort of unnatural freak.

Id agree on Lofton but we had him at age 34...when he was with the pack he was a freak.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Winfield never missed a tackle nor made other critical mistakes. Every so often, Nate would make the huge mistake. A few years ago, he was a big part of why we lost the opener to J'Ville on the last play. That same year, he fumbled a punt against he Steelers in a game we had to have to make the playoffs. I'd go with Winfield.

 

We have had lots of great athletes here. Jerry Butler for one. OJ. Bruce Smith. For a lineman, McKenzie was a great athlete as well. You have to put Lofton on that list. Corneilius Bennett. Nate is a good athlete but I never saw him as some sort of unnatural freak.

Id agree on Lofton but we had him at age 34...when he was with the pack he was a freak.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

While we are on the subject of Top 10 lists, lets do the all-time biggest draft or free-agent busts in Bills history

 

1. Erik Flowers

2. Mike Williams

3. JD Williams

4. Drew Bledsoe

5. Lawyer Milloy

6. Todd Collins

7.

8.

9.

10.

 

Help me out........

Link to comment
Share on other sites

×
×
  • Create New...