Wrong, Lindell best year were his first year at Seattle and last year with the bills:
2000 15-17 88.2%
2001 20-32 62.5%
2002 23-29 79.3%
2003 17-24 70.8%
2004 24-28 85.7%
In fact in his first year he was 7-8 from 40-49 yards and 3-3 beyond 50 yards.
As far as mannys contentions, Haddad dropped several passes plus fumbled a punt return that was nullified because of a penalty. Reed basically had 1 drop per game, but he flat out outplayed the rest of the receivers during preseason, and was getting open. Dorenbos has issues not only with the actual snap but the coaches have also said he couldn't block at all, once he snapped the ball leaving the middle open, and forcing some weird kicks to compensate.