Jump to content

Billy in 4C

Community Member
  • Posts

    578
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by Billy in 4C

  1. Mack - trading for Cleveland's #4 or Oak #5. Cleveland wants a QB but can't justify it at #4 - similar to the Bills with EJ last year. We can't get a guy to fall, but we can certainly try to hype up the guys around him - which is what we've been doing all week...

  2. This is a total garbage signing...

     

    I watch a lot of Giants football here in NYC. Rivers is injury prone, invisible in games and rarely ever will make a standout play. Nobody here cares that he's gone.

     

    If people here don't like negativity around scrap heap signings, the Bills need to stop with the scrap heap signings. This one is a classic. Hope its for depth.

     

    I don't disagree with you - I just think their threshold with this one is "is he equal to or better than Moats" and I think the answer is yes. They clearly aren't "going for it" with these signings. These just keep us in the 5-8 win range.

  3. Byrd was leaving no matter what. He stated that he went to NO because of the "winning culture". Got tired of losing in B'Lo. He was a good player, but he will be easily replaced. No FS is worth what he got in NO.

     

    You say no FS is worth that $ but it means we now must move Aaron Williams who was excellent at SS to FS and now force Searcy/Meeks/Williams/new draft pick into that SS role. None of those guys deserve to start. We might have to make a draft pick to secure a strong safety.

  4. Know why we didn't tag him? We offered 7.5. Tag was 7.8. We didn't think he was WORTH the tag #.

     

    I would have preferred we just kept Hopkins over Carpenter and spent that extra $ on Byrd to get to the $9m. We would have had similar if not the same results on the kicking and could have kept Byrd.

  5. I think we 1 step better with dumping the Toronto series and EJs 2nd season, but 1-2 steps worse (so far) with the losses of Pettine / Byrd / other net free agent losses we will incur. I'm thinking 5-6 wins unless something changes on the FA side. Either way, no jump to the next level of 8-10 wins.

  6. I still dont understand why the Bills wouldn't tag Byrd this year.

     

    Why let him walk for nothing?

     

     

    CBF

     

    The only reason you don't tag/trade him is because you don't plan to sign anyone. Meaning the compensation pick is equal to or greater than what we could yield in a trade. It sounds like we're not going to make a push this year in FA.

  7. Your little numbers scheme does not account for Fitz's innate ability to turn the ball over in close games. Repeatedly. Saying, "we would have won if Fitz were our QB in those games" is impossible to defend, no matter how you choose to twist the numbers.

     

    Ok - I didn't say what you quoted, but just for the sake of argument, would we have won the KC and CLE games if Tuel wasn't the QB? If it was, in fact, Fitz?

  8. You can't quote WR stats when we had at 3 different QB's play during the season (granted, Tuel was just half the Cleveland game). I mean you can, but it's just silly.

     

    If AJ Green has another 6+ seasons like his first 3 he is in the NFL Hall of Fame. If Dareus has another 6+ seasons like his first 3 he is a marginal candidate (and probably on the outside looking in) for the Bills Wall of Fame. Big difference

  9. No way. Dareus still has upside. Keep in mind this was a new system.

     

    AJ Green - 98 rec., 1,426 yards, 11 TDs

     

    Top 4 Bills receivers:

     

    Chandler - 53 rec, 655 yds, 2 TD

    Stevie - 52 rec, 597 yds, 3 TD

    Woods - 40 rec, 587 yds, 3 TD,

    Freddie - 47, 387 yds, 1 TD

     

    Combined: 192 rec, 2,226, 9 TDs

     

    AJ Green might have added 2-3 wins based on his redzone production alone in close games. I don't think Dareus added that much to the team. He's a good player but he's not a top 10 NFL player, which Green is.

  10. (Cue Mora voice) Playoffs? Playoffs?C'mon, man!!! Fitzpatrick will NEVER lead any team to the playoffs. Your statement to the contrary is unfounded and is not remotely based in fact. Sure, Fitz will catch lightning in a bottle and win a few games, but the playoffs? Where has Fitz EVER been a winner?

     

    Tuel straight up cost us the Browns and Chiefs games. 2 wins and we are 8-8. Those are gimmes if you just had a QB with a 60-70 rating.

     

    EJ and Lewis were at best slightly below average, QB ratings off 77.7 and 81 respectively. Fitz had a 82 QB rating, which is about his long-term average as a starter with the Bills. With 2 overtime games and other close 4th quarter games that might have been good for another win. I'm not saying I want Fitz to be the long-term starter by any means, just that, if we had Fitz there's a good shot we'd be 9-7 or 8-8 and probably in the playoffs.

×
×
  • Create New...