Jump to content

Ice Cold Bruschi

Community Member
  • Posts

    242
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by Ice Cold Bruschi

  1. In the current league I would say

    1) Belichick

    2) Fisher

    3) Coughlin

    4) Tomlin

    5) Reid

     

    A Hall of Fame QB certainly helps, but I can think of a few HOF coaches without HOF QBs:

    Joe Gibbs

    Bud Grant

    John Madden

    George Halas

    George Allen

    Dick Vermeil (Warner has a chance though...)

    Gibbs had Theisman, HOF'er. Dick Vermiel isn't in the hall and probably won't make it (I think he should) Bud Grant had Fran Tarkenton, HOF'er, George Halas had Sid Luckman, HOF'er, John Madden had the Snake who should be in the HOF but inexplicably isn't. And George Allen never won anything.

     

    Almost a total fail on your part, plus only gibbs and halas would even come close to the top 10 coaches all time.

  2. He's a really good coach but you give him way too much credit. He made his mark with the Giants but it was a team that already had a top 10 defense and maybe teh greatest defensive player on it already. His record before lucking into a Hall of Fame QB was a Jauron like 41-57.

     

    Again, he is a really good but so overrated and I won't put him in my top 10 NFL coaches list.

    Who is in your top 10? I assume you're talking all-time because he's easily #1 in the present nfl. Because I garauntee all of them had a hall of fame qb.

  3. Stop with the Tebow love. Tebow is a guy who has a lot of scouts who feel that he is not a pro QB the guys leadership and character mean nothing. Winning leads to leadership period. Do you think that Tebow can come in and yell at a guy like Lynch or TO. TO would look at a guy like Tebow and say who the !@#$ are you I turned in an MVP like performance in the Super Bowl coming off a broken leg who cares what you did in the BCS title game.

     

    Look at Eli Manning people in New York were calling him Sheli Manning than he won the Super Bowl and than overnight he is the Man a guy who is cool calm and collected under pressure. Winning equates to leadership in the NFL. No one cares what you did while you were in college so Tebow and his "Leadership" won't translate to the NFL.

     

    The only guys who love Tebow are usually the ones who have a connection to him. Either local media, alumni, or beat writers who have a close connection to him. People who take an objective look at him say he just doesn't have first round talent. And unless his new throwing motion changes their minds I don't see the objective scouts changing their minds about him.

     

    Yeah seriously, look at what all that "leadership" has done for Matt Leinart and Vince Young, both better college QB's than Tebow.

  4. Oh, I have a feeling that will be a lot of people who COULD quote you on this for the rest of your life, but won't. A lot of people would have dumped on college players like:

     

    • Joe Montana (3rd round)
    • Tom Brady (6th round)
    • John Unitas (9th round)
    • Mike Webster (5th round)
    • John Stallworth (4th round)
    • Roger Staubach (10th round)
    • Bart Starr (17th round)

    I doubt that very many people took the time to go back and tell off the spoonhead who said, "Bart Starr is gonna be an NFL bust". They were too busy watching NFL history being made. Even if Tebow doesn't live up to the hype, and I think he will, he brings an attitude that a lot of teams in general and the Bills in particular, could sorely use. He's won at every level and the team that drafts him is going to get an exceptional person and athlete.

     

    So I promise not to say, "I told you so".

    Lets examine a few of those players you mentioned, the QB's specifically since we're comparing them to Tebow.

     

    Joe Montana- Notre Dame, long long history of great NFL players, pro style offense, multiple HOF QB's, tons of HOF'ers and tons of solid players

    Tom Brady- Michigan, long long history of great NFL players, not so much QB's but still there have been a few to have long careers in the NFL such as Brian Griese and Todd Collins

    John Unitas-anomoly

    Roger Staubach- was drafted so late because he was in the Navy and was going to Vietnam

    Bart Starr- played for Alabama another school that has produced a myriad of hall of famers and another HOF QB, and a pretty much inexhaustable list of solid players

     

     

    Then you look at Florida, bust after bust after bust after bust. Tebow is going to be Danny Weurffle/Rex Grossman part deux.

     

    Your logic is faulty you're trying to say that because there have been players selected in late rounds who succeeded, Tebow (who will likely go in the 1st or 2nd) will succeed?

     

    The knocks on the QB's you mentioned were physical (except Staubach) my grudge against Tebow is that he can't play in an NFL style offense, and his success is due to the fact that he's basically playing a different game.

  5. Frankly I think the biggest insult here Jason, is that you're insinuating that Jasper and Caveman are racists. If anyone called me a racist I'd punch them square in the nose, thats how offended I'd be. Its more insulting than being called a cracker or a honky thats for sure. It questions everything about a person, it calls into question their up bringing, their intelligence as well as their entire view of reality. You really should be more consciencious when you throw around the word racist

  6. See, this is what I don't understand about Juaron, why I think he's a horrible coach. Your offense last year sucked horribly and was going 3 and out and you were getting killed in time of possession and your defense was really tired. So his conclusion is "Hmmm why don't we implement the hurry up offense so we can get off the field even faster!". You guys don't have the talent to do it I don't understand why you aren't trying to play smash mouth football with marshawn and jackson, or play a spread and give them some draws, screens and what have you, and have Evans and TO stretch the field while giving it to reed and Roscoe underneath. The hurry up is just a horrible idea for your offense right now. Thats just my two sense. They should just use it situationally, not just use it for the sake of using it.

  7. Quote me on this the rest of my life if you want. Tim Tebow will do nothing in the NFL NOTHING. The list of successful UF QB's in the NFL? 0 (unless you want to count rex grossman who rode the bears to a superbowl but I don't think anyone wants to stick up for him) Hell the list of successful UF players in the NFL is a short one anyway regardless of position. Jack Youngblood and Emmitt Smith are two hall of famers yes. But other than that you have some guys who are very few and far between like Kevin Carter and Fred Taylor, and absolutely no one in the last 10 years.

     

    Tebow is all hype (NFL prospectwise I mean, not to say he isn't one of the greatest college QB's ever) and any team that drafts him in the first round to be their savior is foolish.

     

     

    and why would you dismiss Bradford more easily than Tebow anyway? Bradford plays in a gimmicky spread system, but Tebow plays in THE gimmicky spread system. They're both gonna be NFL busts.

     

    Colt McCoy is way better than either of them.

  8. I hate Jerry Jones as much as the next red blooded American, but the guy is gonna be in the hall of fame AND he has 3 super bowl rings (and unfortunately will probably have more by the time he retires) He's head and shoulders a better football man than Ralph, maybe Ralph has a heart of gold or whatever you want to think, but if I had to choose I'd take Jones everytime over Ralph, because winning matters

  9. You know who IS a lot like the 07 Pats? The 09 Pats.

     

    Moss

    Welker

    Stallworth

    Brady

    Maroney/Morris/Faulk

    Light

    Mankins

    Koppen

    Neal

    Kaczur

    Watson

     

    Moss

    Welker

    Galloway

    Brady

    Maroney/Taylor/Morris/Faulk/Green-Ellis

    Light

    Mankins

    Koppen

    Neal

    Vollmer

    Watson/Baker/Smith

  10. There are four New England Patriots in the Pro Football Hall of Fame - Nick Buoniconti, John Hannah, Mike Haynes, and Andre Tippett. None of them are quarterbacks, moron.

     

    (As of the 2008 season, seven Buffalo Bills are in the Pro Football Hall of Fame - O.J. Simpson, Joe Delamielleure, Marv Levy, Thurman Thomas, James Lofton, Billy Shaw, and Jim Kelly. This weekend, we'll add Bruce Smith and Ralph Wilson.)

    Ok we both know Brady is a 1st ballot hof qb, we'll also be adding Randy Moss, Bill Belichick, Richard Seymour (and possibly Bruschi and Harrison)

×
×
  • Create New...