Personally I think they both suck.
Sorry but Edwards was not impressive yesterday. He should thank God for a defense that held Seattle in Check while he missed open receivers and gave Brian Moorman all the work he could handle.
Against a potent offense which will score against our defense, his inadequacies will be exposed.
As for JP, well what can I say, the dude has had his shot on numerous occasion and under performed.
Like the guy but its time to move on