Jump to content

Nephilim17

Community Member
  • Posts

    2,530
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by Nephilim17

  1.  

    2 hours ago, PBF81 said:

    I feel sorry for her.  

     

    There's a very good article about the situation linked on the homepage.  

     

    https://www.reviewjournal.com/sports/sports-columns/adam-hill/hill-spare-me-your-outrage-and-maybe-spare-bills-reporters-job-2905797/

     

    I'm sure she's crushed over it.  She's probably been crying frequently since it was put out.  

     

    My question is who was so eager to put that out.  Kind of a big nothing-burger that's been made into a mountain.  

     

     

    I"m not a fan of Maddy — no insight and looks like a hire made to stop trotting out middle-aged men as commentators — but this article is fair and her comments were not that bad, especially considering she thought it was a private convo. And whoever leaked it was not ultimately trying to help the team.

    • Like (+1) 1
    • Agree 1
  2. 10 hours ago, Mango said:

    The more I sit with this the more I see it similar to Michael Irvin. You can tell Josh to play smart. You can yell at him. But you can’t signal to the public that he’s dumb (pointing at your head).

     

    Palmer doesn’t help here. By publicly saying  “He misses Daboll” he’s also saying “Josh is broken and needs help”.

     

    But also…WTF does Josh pay this guy for. It’s week 1 and this was a mess. How can a private QB coach be like “It’s the OC” after spending more time with him than anybody in the offseason? And then be like “The real secret sauce isn’t me or his current OC, it’s the HC of the Giants?

    Exactly. Palmer saying this a) diminishes Josh's abilities (the greatness could only be harnessed by one man who isn't Josh and b) makes Palmer's influence seem insignificant.

     

    Josh IS responsible for his poor play week 1 and league-leading turnover over long stretches of time and needs to be held accountable. But Palmer should be more careful when discussing his clients in public.

×
×
  • Create New...