Jump to content

respk

Community Member
  • Posts

    415
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by respk

  1. Beane did exactly what I've wanted the Bills to do. That is to pick a franchise QB and get him no matter what it takes. Whether Allen becomes a franchise QB remains to be seen, but they took a chance and did something. I'm tired of watching the Bills sit back and wait for something to happen. If Allen doesn't work out then Beane and McDermott may be gone and rightfully so.

  2.  

    I looked at the number of players we drafted from 2013-2016, how many remained with the team, and how many are still in NFL. The latter is very important because that is an indicator of your "ability" to spot talent in the drafts. I then compared your performance to that of our esteemed rivals, New England Patriots. And the results are interesting:

    gXIOLGP.png

    In those 4 years we drafted 28 players to Pats' 36. Of the 28, 15 still remain with the team as of today. That's 54%. Looking at the pats, of the 36, 18 players are still on their roster as of today. So we have exceeded Pats' team retention by 4%. Nice.

    Now let's look at over-all talent evaluation. How many of our players are still on NFL rosters, vs. those who are no longer NFL players. Of the 28 players we drafted, 24 are still in the league, or 86%. Of the 36 players the esteemed Pats drafted, only 27 remain in the NFL. That's 75%. Here, Bills and Whaley have outperformed World Champions by 11% points.

     

    Doug, it is clear now. it's not your fault this team hasn't won. You can only bring them in. You aren't the one coaching them.

     

     

     

    Kind of like winning the off season.

  3. Unfortunately, given what is available this is probably the best for this season and maybe next. Hopefully the Bills continue to attempt to find the "franchise" QB to start next year and beyond. We'll be in the same position in 2 years again. No franchise QB, too much cap space taken up by other positions with little to no cap space for the most important position on the field. All cheer mediocrity.

  4. I've always given the Pegulas the benefit of the doubt, but they screwed up big time today. To throw Lynn to the wolves at the first presser after firing Ryan and the first to answer why TT was being benched was amateurish at best. If I'm Lynn, I would do everything possible to find another HC job in another organization before I'd sign with the Bills. Whaley at least and better yet the Pegulas should have pulled up their big boy pants and held the first press conference after the Ryan firing not Lynn.

  5.  

    Well...The problem is no one can cover...They're basically damned if they do and damned if they don't...

     

    ryan needs to change up the defense then. Unfortunately the Ryan's appear to be a one trick pony. When their one trick doesn't work they don't have a plan B. This isn't the first game where the corners get beat on every play.

  6. I think that the Bills are in the best QB shape that they have been in since the 1990's. I don't see them looking for another guy that you hope can get to the level that Tyrod just played at. That is what you are talking about with the guy you will be considering. Goff is off the board and everyone else has serious flaws.

     

    Realistically, maybe 2 of these QBs turn out better than Taylor. One of them is likely to be Goff. With that being said we have to pick the 1 other guy out of ALL of the QBs coming out that may be as good as Tyrod. That is asking a lot. We are not in the desperate place that we have been for years when it was ignored. If Losman or Edwards or EJ or Holcomb were under center than yes, you take your chances. The Bills aren't in that situation. They are in search of a long-term answer as a backup. It is more likely than not that Tyrod is the guy. If he is not the Bills will be picking early next year and have a chance to get the franchise guy. Reaching for a 2nd tier guy isn't going to upgrade the starting position IMO.

    Granted the future at QB is brighter with Taylor and he may turn out to be that franchise QB, but very little has been proven yet. Given the importance of the position teams have to keep trying to find that franchise QB. One of the biggest reasons the Bills haven't made the playoffs in 16 years is because they haven't found that QB. In rounds 2 & 3 you're looking for that diamond, but you just have to take that chance year after year until the right QB is found. Mediocre with an excellent defense isn't good enough anymore to win the Super Bowl.

  7.  

    I used the Fanspeak Draft Simulator, and selected players. What do you think of the players selected and any changes?
    Round 1: Myles Jack, UCLA OLB
    Round 2: Adolphus Washington, Ohio State DT
    Round 3: Rashard Higgins, Colorado State WR
    Round 4: Daryl Worley, WVU CB
    Round 5: Max Redfield, Notre Dame Safety
    Round 6: Kevin Hogan, Stanford QB
    The Bills do not have a 7th Round Pick.

     

    They should be picking a QB in round 2 or 3.

  8. I wasn't completely sold on the Ryan hire, but I thought at least they were trying to get a big "name" guy and hoped it would work out. It hasn't. After watching the season so far, I'd fire Ryan in a heart beat. I don't like the way they get beat. The penalties, the poor game management, players taking plays off, the play calling on offense and defense, implementing his scheme even though he doesn't have the players to run it (it appears), Rex acknowledging he was outcoached in 3 or 4 games, etc. I don't believe Rex can fix those problems in the next year or two. The Bills can fire Rex now or they will be doing it in 1-2 years. I just don't see Rex turning this around in however much time he has here. I'm less inclined to fire Whaley, but I would bring in a football czar. Someone whose built successful teams in the past hopefully. That doesn't mean they will again, but maybe they're closer than someone who hasn't.

  9. The continuity of the organization is a valid point. However, I think it's time to let Rex go. He's fallen on his sword by admitting he is the weakest link, he got outcoached at least twice and the team follows his lead and isn't very disciplined. Will Rex suddenly change his stripes next year? I doubt it. Fire him now and get on with continuity starting next year. If Rex stays, most likely we see more of the same next year and miss the playoffs. He might get a third year, but there's no reason to expect that the results will be any different. Rex doesn't seem able to make adjustments in how he coaches, Prime example is this year's defense. He seemingly refused to adjust his scheme to the talent and the defense took a huge step backwards. Get the pain over with now and move on. Continuity is only good when you have the right people in place. Rex has done nothing to indicate he is the right coach.

×
×
  • Create New...