Jump to content

TheCockSportif

Community Member
  • Posts

    1,896
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by TheCockSportif

  1. 3 minutes ago, Phil The Thrill said:

    I think that part of the problem was that Tyrod was being positions as the team’s answer at QB after 2015.  At the time, we didn’t know where his ceiling was.  I think that it was understood that he was a placeholder for a rookie, that fans would have been a bit more forgiving 

     

    Without question TT was the best answer going into 2016.  No way I was going to talk myself into EJ again or to Cardale freaking Jones.  We don't know what the org believed because Rex would say anything at any given time -- in an attempt to pump up a lackluster coaching effort.

     

    I will say that in my lifetime I have witnessed the following players under center for the Bills (excluding guys like Flutie and Kelly and Fergy and Bledsoe, obviously in no specific order), and it was underwhelming to say the least:

    • Joe Dufek
    • Vince Ferragamo
    • Matt Kofler
    • Bruce Mathison
    • Alex Van Pelt
    • Billy Joe Hobert
    • Rob Johnson
    • Travis Brown
    • Kelly Holcomb
    • Brian Brohm
    • Trent Edwards
    • Levi Brown
    • Tyler Thigpen
    • Jeff Tuel
    • Thad Lewis
    • EJ Manuel
    • JP Losman

    And that's really just the tip of the iceberg.  I have seen astoundingly lousy quarterback play from this team since I became conscious of watching OJ and crew in my grandparents' apartment in Buffalo, in 1974.  Other QBs have adorned us with their presence, and that list above was just off the top of my head.

     

    Given what I noted above though, TT was way, way more stable than any of those cats.  If you come back and say that TT was JAG then I agree.  I can't argue that TT was the organization's only plan though.  Because until the coaching regime and FO changed, I'm not entirely sure that they had a plan.

     

     

  2. 5 hours ago, Buffalo Boy said:

    ???

    Bledsoe in his first year and Fitz we’re both decidedly better.

    Not throwing the ball anywhere NEAR a defender has a way of skewing TTs stats.

    Two games to watch: The playoff game and the Carolina game. One at the beginning of the season and one at the end. They tell you all you’ll ever need to know about TTs lack ofQB acumen.

    I don't get the dislike of TT.  I really don't.  Was he going to elevate his play and take the Bills to the playoffs on a regular basis, deep into the playoffs, and/or to the Super Bowl?  Probably not, if almost certainly not.  But I remain of the opinion that he brought stability (not greatness, but stability) to the QB position while the team tried to figure the roster out.  EJ was a flame out.  Orton wasn't coming back.  Cassel, uh, no.  Peterman, definitely no.  Etc, etc, etc. 

     

    Getting rid of the lousy FO situation, bringing in capable coaching, and yes having TT under center in the interim finally seems to have stabilized my favorite moribund NFL team.

    • Like (+1) 3
  3. 1 minute ago, OldTimeAFLGuy said:

     

    ...his five year, $10 million dollar contract went up in flames because of his indiscretions...BUT...Pegula did give him $2 million severance.......at the same time, he is forever blacklisted from ANY employment in Buffalo and remains unemployed......even his buddy Koch who owns New Era said, "no can do".......Pegs does have some (COUGH) "influence"...

    Hope that Brandon is a frugal guy, and again, hope that he never touches another Buffalo sports team again, or is prominent in the area again... ever.

    • Awesome! (+1) 1
  4. 1 minute ago, OldTimeAFLGuy said:

     

    ...and I do know that Brandon called Fitz in asking him to re-negotiate for backup money.....Fitz said, "nope I will get starter money somewhere"........which he ironically did and STILL does.....

    Speaking of Brandon?  Glad that dude is gone once and for all.  I grew sick of hearing about him.

     

    Good on Fitz though.  Had EJ been able to manage his crisis of confidence then he too would probably still be in the league somewhere.

    • Awesome! (+1) 1
  5. 1 minute ago, OldTimeAFLGuy said:

     

     

    objectively (I have no ax to grind or want to play the blame game) I think it was a combination of both.....Nix was hell bent on drafting a QB...ironically his 1st choice was Gnome Smith until they flew down for interview and work out...consensus on the plane ride home was, "um...no thanks"......so EJ was 2nd fiddle......I don't think his self-confidence level would rise to being overdrafted nor do I think his collegiate career demonstrated a HIGH ceiling......think he did show a good work ethic and tried to improve...but as Steve Young (yup THAT guy) said, "more collegians fail versus succeed at the NFL level due to the speed and complexity of the game".......

     

    Kind of agree.  It was a comedy of errors, and this could be said for the Bills from 2000 until 2016 (give or take).  Nix gave a huge extension to Fitz then found himself needing to get the money back to draft other talent and to sign FAs.  I don't blame EJ for having been drafted that early; that was on the Bills.  Sadly for EJ -- he was just not a good QB.

  6. 2 minutes ago, Phil The Thrill said:


    They really didn’t have to use a high pick on a QB.  There probably were other options than Kevin Kolb.  They didn’t have to let Fitz walk and they could have always signed a vet to compete in 2012 and he did one of his legendary Fitzpatrick late season tanks.  
     

    But they painted themselves into this situation and it turned out terrible - thank you Buddy Nix and Doug Whaley

     

    I totally agree that this was a Whaley/Nix debacle.  Nix painted himself into a corner with Fitz's contract extension as memory serves, and when he asked Fitz to renegotiate after 1+ years, Fitz was like, "nope."

     

    To your point, organizational ineptitude at the time brought us EJ.

  7. Oh god.  EJ is back on the board.

     

    In any case, the Bills had to pick somebody for the position in 2013 (as they should have from 2010 on).  Whether it was EJ or whether it was Geno Smith, the team would be in the same spot with regard to yet another wasted pick.  Of course, we can all draw this conclusion with the benefit of hindsight.

     

    Lost decades of competitive football due to horrible scouting and a horrible FO/coaching regime did this team in.  EJ was just the exclamation point on top of it all.

     

    Just my $0.02 obviously.

    • Like (+1) 1
  8. 4 hours ago, Cripple Creek said:

    SD moved because of issues between ownership and local government.

    I'm not sure that it's accurate to say that SD moved because of issues with local government alone.  Both parties acted in the hopes of funding a new stadium, but in the end government punted and there was a referendum.  If memory serves, even Rams' ownership considered helping foot the bill for a new stadium in SD.

  9. 10 minutes ago, Joe in Winslow said:

     

    Did you or did you not call for him to be drafted

    Does it really matter now though, Joe?  I was as shocked (and disappointed) as anybody else when the Bills didn't draft Mahomes.  But at some point it doesn't matter anymore.  For me it was shortly after that draft -- where you realize that as a fan all you can do is to hope that riding with Peterman and Taylor was a bridge to drafting another QB in the first round later.  Which they did.

     

     

  10. 1 hour ago, Billsfan1972 said:

    Actually the Bills may have been 13-3 & gotten a bye & home field advantage......  Got to dream big!!!!!?

     

    Get over the trade & where he was picked.  He was productive as a Bill (1000 yard Season) & under contract.  He certainly was better then Gaines who we traded him for (& injured btw) or Matthews who the Bills replaced Watkins with????

     

     http://www.nfl.com/player/jordanmatthews/2543500/careerstats

     

    Boy that was a trade!!!!

    Watkins had his moments, but when you look at the value of the pick, in particular given his injury history, and given what he disclosed about his effort here during an interview when he was with LAR, a change needed to be made.

  11. Watkins, though.  Yes, I was gobsmacked when he got drafted with that crazy trade of picks.  And yes, I was surprised that they tried to bolster the raw potential of EJ Manuel (that was sarcasm) by drafting Watkins.

     

    Still, people have to let this go.  Different ownership.  Different FO and coaching regime.  Beane hasn't been lights out on the O side of the ball, but most certainly he didn't Whaley his FA or draft choices.  It's been probably 30 years since this organization did anything rational, and the past couple of years has shown that they are willing to part with dead weight.  While I'm glad that Watkins is gone, I think of his non existence here in the same light as Mahomes not having been the pick in 2017.  Time to move on.

     

    Groin OUT!

  12. Just now, Joe in Winslow said:


    Well, it's conceivable he's just an a-hole, too.

     

    That's within the realm of possibility, yes?

     

    This, exactly.  I initially thought that AB had buyer's remorse after having landed in OAK -- dollars be damned -- and also after the Pats almost certainly interfered with him when he was in OAK and was looking for an out. 

     

    But the fact that he crapped the bed with the Pats as well is a testament to what happens when an organization ties itself to talent alone -- and doesn't take into consideration the aspects of character and/or of professionalism.  AB is deeply flawed, and who knows the reason for this.  Maybe he has CTE (I hope not for his sake) or maybe he's just an insufferable human being.  Who knows?  I suppose that what shakes out in 2020 will be our guide.

  13. 2 hours ago, Hapless Bills Fan said:

     

    With the benefit of hindsight to review McDermott's intro presser, he made a bunch of comments about how he was "comfortable with the situation" at GM and "the Pegulas have made certain that I am comfortable with it, which I appreciate" or words to that effect.

     

    The famous "not privy" presser with Whaley sealed his doom, and he was quickly given a back seat in the coaching search.  He had Whaleyed himself out before McD was hired.

     

    I think, again with the benefit of hindsight to read the tealeaves, that the Pegulas promised McDermott that he could bring in his guy either outright, or if he wasn't 100% satisfied after working with Whaley for some short period of time - and that McDermott had an understanding with Beane before he took the job.

    Correct on all counts.  He totally worked himself out of a job (and it was well deserved, again, with the benefit of hindsight).  Still, the Bills had a GM in their employ when the HC was hired.  Not only was a GM in their employ when the HC was hired, but they kept the GM through the draft.  

     

    I quibbled with a certain person because they argued that the Bills had no GM and no HC -- when the Bills had a GM, or at very least in title, before the HC was hired.  The Browns have no HC and no person who holds the GM title currently.  Plus, it doesn't matter that Whaley might not have had a say in the coaching search.  He was still GM when the HC was hired.

     

    And again, Whaley was GM, at least in title (and he was still drawing a salary) for the 2017 draft, so it's absurd that someone would argue that the Bills had no HC and GM at the same point in 2017.  This argument is demonstrably false, and that is where I took exception.

  14. 1 minute ago, MAJBobby said:


    semantics. But keep trying it is cute. So who was hired first the HC (McD) or the GM (Beane). 

    Semantics?  No.  Plain English?  Yes.

     

    Fact: The Bills had a GM on January 11, 2017 when McD was hired.

     

    Fact: The Bills offered Doug Whaley an extension on January 10, 2016, and fired him on April 30, 2017.

     

    Fact: Beane was hired by the Bills on May 9, 2017.

     

    The Browns have neither a HC nor a GM currently.  This was demonstrably not the case with the Bills in 2017, and that was the nature of my remark before.  Cry semantics all you want, but you were wrong.  Doubling down on being wrong just puts you on airlock.  See ya!

  15. 4 minutes ago, MAJBobby said:


    McD was hired without a GM (Whaley was going to be GONE, hence McD in charge of that draft). And then they brought in Beane. 
     

    I don't know why you are arguing this point.  Whaley was fired right after the draft, and he was still GM at that time.  Sure, he may have been a figurehead, but fact remains that the Bills still had a GM when the HC was hired.

×
×
  • Create New...