Jump to content

Samwell Tarly

Community Member
  • Posts

    450
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by Samwell Tarly

  1.  

    Except Brees, Rivers, and Luck are not routinely in the hunt every year. Brees, the most prolific passer in the NFL since going to the Saints, hasn't made the playoffs or even had a winning record in 5 years. Rivers too. Luck hasn't done anything since his division has improved.

     

    Luck, Brees, Rivers, Ryan, Stafford...5 of the 10 highest paid people in the NFL, and routinely all considered in the top 3 to 10 in the league have 3 playoff appearances combined between them in the last 3 seasons out of 15 opportunities. And Stafford owns 2 of those playoff births who is probably the lesser regarded in that bunch of 5 QB's by most people. People talk about Cam Newton too...yet only 2 winning seasons in 6 years.

    Don't forget also need decent team and coaching. Saints have talent outside Brees, but not cohesive. Chargers have similar problems, plus have changed coaches. The colts... Have Luck and little else since Arians left. Don't even get me started on the Lions...
  2. Luck along with Brees and Rivers are perfect examples of why the whole "just need a QB" crowd are dead wrong.

     

    You need a complete team and a solid coaching staff along with good fortune or cheating to get ahead in this league.

    You do need more than just a quarterback, but you do need the quarterback. With one, along with good coaching and a good team, you're in the hunt pretty much every year. Without one, you need an elite defense to succeed, and its usually not as sustainable. Below average qb and average talent, your on the 5 to 8 win treadmill until you fix the problem.
  3. Successful teams build around foundational players. The quarterback, of course is most important and the hardest piece to acquire. The other foundation players are usually offensive linemen , defensive line, or linebackers.

     

    The Bills haven't had the most important pillar since Kelly.

     

    Great Wide receivers are very entertaining, but only a few take on leadership roles. Plus they only touch the ball a few times a game.

    Few running backs last long enough to fill this role either.

    So I can see why a new coach would do what he feels is necessary to get a franchise qb and some core players that he can count on. All the other players come and go anyway.

  4. The trick as a coach is to survive until you can build your team, primarily through the draft. Roster turnover happens faster in the NFL now, but still takes more than 2 or 3 seasons. No Bills coach since Marv has lasted long enough to build an entire team of their guys. Its also hard for a coach to last beyond season 3 without a quality quarterback.

  5. Tough to argue with Rice, he was the total package.

    Moss was awesome too, the most physically gifted I've seen, but

    Megatron is right on his heels.

    Sterling Sharpe also awesome, made Farce and his gunslinger style work because he could catch about anything.

    As Bills go, Andre Reed for sure. So many great catches during the golden years of this franchise.

×
×
  • Create New...