Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted
2 minutes ago, Kirby Jackson said:

We are talking regression like, “they might be 7-10.” They were never winning less than 10 games. That was automatic. Now if the concern was, “maybe they limp in as a WC and get beat in round 1” that was reasonable. The thought that the bottom could fall out was not. 
 

We aren’t drawing any conclusions now. That’s kind of the point. The Bills were going to be right around here regardless of who was coaching. 

The chiefs won 6 games last year with Mahomes playing all but a couple.  Who had that on their bingo card? It is NOT a given to win 10 games even with Mahomes or Allen.  It is highly probable, we have been spoiled.  I want nothing more than what we l want but I have concerns with some of Brady’s decisions and the noise will get really loud if they lose some games based on those.  We also need a dramatic improvement on defense to truly contend.  
 

go bills 

  • Disagree 2
Posted (edited)
1 hour ago, Matt_In_NH said:

The chiefs won 6 games last year with Mahomes playing all but a couple.  Who had that on their bingo card? It is NOT a given to win 10 games even with Mahomes or Allen.  It is highly probable, we have been spoiled.  I want nothing more than what we l want but I have concerns with some of Brady’s decisions and the noise will get really loud if they lose some games based on those.  We also need a dramatic improvement on defense to truly contend.  
 

go bills 

Josh makes too many plays on his own to even look like the Chiefs. He can just go out there and create 3+ TDs in a game. As great as Mahomes is, he’s not like that. He doesn’t score like Josh does. Josh is 17+ points a game. 
 

This isn’t a post supporting Brady. It’s a post supporting change. Brady has accomplished what we all expected but there have been times that are concerning. The Bills were going to win 10+ though with Webb or Udinski or Weaver or Rivers or Brady or whomever. Moving on from McDermott wasn’t any risk. That’s proving to be true. Selecting Brady is still very much an unknown.

Edited by Kirby Jackson
  • Like (+1) 2
  • Disagree 1
Posted
20 hours ago, Chaos said:

Many TBD poster were concerned for the last couple of years that changing McDermott meant a return to the "drought era". 

 

Some of them were so confident that they were practically rooting for it! Embarrassing.

Posted
11 hours ago, GoBills808 said:

we've changed offensive schemes and OCs like what 4x w Allen?

 

every iteration a success

 

Actually every iteration was not a success.  Ken Dorsey ran a pass heavy offense in which Allen threw his lowest % of TDs (5.0%) and highest percentage of INTs (3.1%) as well as highest number of INTs (18) in his career in 2023.  Dorsey was fired in mid-November 2023 after the Bills lost 24-22 to the Broncos at home, giving them a 5-5 record 10 games into the season.   Brady took over the offense and the Bills went on a 6-1 run to finish the season 11-6.  The next season under Brady, Allen won the MVP, the Bills finished 13-4, and went to the AFCCG.

 

8 hours ago, ganesh said:

The Bills were never going to be a bad team this season irrespective who was going to be the HC. That is because they have 17. 
 

 

If the Bills had hired John Harbaugh instead of Brady, Harbaugh would have brought in his buddy Greg Roman as OC (which is what he did with the Giants) who would have used Allen like he did Lamar Jackson in Baltimore and Justin Hebert with the LA Chargers ... and likely gotten him beat up like both of those QBs were beat up being used as hybrid QB/RBs rather than what he is, an elite QB who uses his legs as a judiciously used super power.   If Allen survived the season, my guess is that he would have been really hurting come playoff time just as both Lamar and Herbert were hurting at the end of their seasons under Roman.

 

A mediocre defense and a beat up QB is a prescription for a disappointing season even if it's not "bad" compared to the rest of the NFL.

 

Many Bills fans don't realize that Beane has been dedicated to maximizing Josh Allen's potential since he drafted him.  Daboll, Dorsey, Brady, and Carmichael were all chosen to fit with Allen rather than trying to remake Allen into something else.  Brady's relationship with Allen was probably the reason that the Bills chose Brady as HC.  Even as HC, Brady not only calls the plays but he also consults with Allen during the game. 

 

 

 

 

1 hour ago, Kirby Jackson said:

Fair. Dorsey wasn’t good but they were still 18-8 in his tenure (plus 2-2 in the playoffs). They averaged 26.2 PPG in the year he was fired. As I’ve learned throughout the discussions about adding a WR from some, “your offense scores a lot of points so there must be no room to improve.” (Just kidding) Dorsey was the least capable person put near Josh Allen. He was so far over his head. He followed his tenure here by last a dozen games in Cleveland where he had the worst offense in football. Sure, it’s the Browns but he was certainly an anchor there. 

 

Is this the group to get the Bills to the Super Bowl? I have no idea. There have been a bunch of cringe-worthy decisions. The flip side is I did not expect 6-1 at this point. The 1 seed would be a nice boost but I think that’s going to be tough looking at Jacksonville & Cincinnati’s schedules.

 

  • Disagree 2
Posted
41 minutes ago, SoTier said:

 

Actually every iteration was not a success.  Ken Dorsey ran a pass heavy offense in which Allen threw his lowest % of TDs (5.0%) and highest percentage of INTs (3.1%) as well as highest number of INTs (18) in his career in 2023.  Dorsey was fired in mid-November 2023 after the Bills lost 24-22 to the Broncos at home, giving them a 5-5 record 10 games into the season.   Brady took over the offense and the Bills went on a 6-1 run to finish the season 11-6.  The next season under Brady, Allen won the MVP, the Bills finished 13-4, and went to the AFCCG.

 

 

If the Bills had hired John Harbaugh instead of Brady, Harbaugh would have brought in his buddy Greg Roman as OC (which is what he did with the Giants) who would have used Allen like he did Lamar Jackson in Baltimore and Justin Hebert with the LA Chargers ... and likely gotten him beat up like both of those QBs were beat up being used as hybrid QB/RBs rather than what he is, an elite QB who uses his legs as a judiciously used super power.   If Allen survived the season, my guess is that he would have been really hurting come playoff time just as both Lamar and Herbert were hurting at the end of their seasons under Roman.

 

A mediocre defense and a beat up QB is a prescription for a disappointing season even if it's not "bad" compared to the rest of the NFL.

 

Many Bills fans don't realize that Beane has been dedicated to maximizing Josh Allen's potential since he drafted him.  Daboll, Dorsey, Brady, and Carmichael were all chosen to fit with Allen rather than trying to remake Allen into something else.  Brady's relationship with Allen was probably the reason that the Bills chose Brady as HC.  Even as HC, Brady not only calls the plays but he also consults with Allen during the game. 

 

 

 

 

 

The Giants hired John Harbaugh on January 17, 2026. The Bills fired Sean McDermott on January 19, 2026. 

Posted
6 hours ago, Chandler#81 said:

Here’s one. Emergency QB starter in our disastrous ‘68 season brought real spark! Then, he joined Dan Darragh, Jack Kemp, Tom Flores and a couple other guys on season ending IR..🤦‍♂️ BUT!  he later became Head Coach of the Bills!

Kay Stevenson 

 

 

Until this moment I literally had no idea re KS was a Bills QB. My only excuse is that I was barely out of the womb at the time. Good day when you learn something new. Thanks Chandler.

Posted
4 hours ago, Matt_In_NH said:

The chiefs won 6 games last year with Mahomes playing all but a couple.


Mahomes has not played well for a few years now. 

  • Like (+1) 2
  • Agree 1
Posted
4 minutes ago, Einstein said:


Mahomes has not played well for a few years now. 

Allen also has 55 more TDs than Mahomes since 2020...that's more than a full season's worth of TDs from the QB spot. it's an unheard of competitive advantage

 

 

  • Like (+1) 2
Posted
6 minutes ago, Einstein said:


Mahomes has not played well for a few years now. 

Like the Buffalo Bills, they are desperate for an X-boundary WR who can separate and get open to stretch the field. We see the same thing with Josh Allen when DJ Moore is not on the field...except Josh is an elite alien unicorn. 😆 Mahomes looks ordinary without that big-play WR now.  

  • Like (+1) 3
Posted
2 hours ago, Kirby Jackson said:

The Giants hired John Harbaugh on January 17, 2026. The Bills fired Sean McDermott on January 19, 2026. 

 

I knew that Harbaugh wasn't available, but I didn't realize that he was hired before the Bills even fired McDermott.    My example was hypothetical because many Bills fans dreamed of Harbaugh becoming the Bills HC.   That was never me.  I dislike both Harbaughs.

Posted
1 hour ago, Nihilarian said:

Like the Buffalo Bills, they are desperate for an X-boundary WR who can separate and get open to stretch the field. We see the same thing with Josh Allen when DJ Moore is not on the field...except Josh is an elite alien unicorn. 😆 Mahomes looks ordinary without that big-play WR now.  

 

 

 

I also believe that teams have caught onto Mahomes shenanigans, scrambling around in the backfield, dancing around at the edge of the side lines, etc. and have purposely game planned for this.

Posted

You know what I find exceedingly odd is that the Dallas Cowboys have a top-ten passing offense, two top WRs in Lamb and Pickens, yet still stink. A decent QB, although with a bad run game/defense, and they are 3-5 and can't get out of their own way.

 

Therefore, I think their coaching staff stinks...but then the GM is also the owner. They should fire their GM for trading away Micah Parsons 😂...speaking of him, the Patriots probably won't have to face him, and Buffalo just might. 

Posted

There is a statistic I kept pointing out this summer, and I'll continue to do that.

No Head Coach/Quarterback combination has ever won their first Super Bowl together after being paired together for 5 years.

 

John Elway couldn't do it with Dan Reeves, but did with Mike Shanahan.

Peyton Manning couldn't do it with Jim Mora, but did with Tony Dungy.

Andy Reid couldn't do it with Donovon McNabb, but did with Patrick Mahomes.

 

The HC and QB are arguably the most important pieces to any franchise, especially when you consider overall leadership.

After so many years of falling short, I think the rest of the team stops believing they can get over the hump, and something needs to change.

 

Sean McDermott is a good coach, and he will have success in the NFL again.  But after 13 seconds, I think the doubts started creeping into the locker room.  With each ensuing playoff loss, the message became more tired and stale.  Every season more of his supporters switched sides, and the Denver loss was the breaking point.

 

Whether Joe Brady was the correct replacement remains to be seen.  Despite the record, I'm not terribly impressed with what I've seen so far.

  • The team has been ridiculously sloppy and unfocused.  Penalties.  Turnovers.  Drops.  Still playing down to lesser opponents.
  • Game, clock and injury management has taken a massive step backwards.  
  • Our first risky character signing lasted less than 6 games before getting ejected, suspended and cut.  
  • Offense is a wash.  Defense is worse.
  • Like (+1) 1
Posted

All this talk of Josh Allen being an automatic 10+win QB is crazy talk, in my view, as we all saw in that 2023 season under Bills OC Ken Dorsey. Allen finished that 2023 season with 29 TDs, 18 INTs, and 7 fumbles.  @SoTierHe is correct in his thinking, IMHO.

 

https://www.espn.com/nfl/story/_/id/38896424/bills-offensive-coordinator-ken-dorsey-fired-sources-say

 

("But Dorsey's firing also comes as a response to a Bills team that sits at 5-5, falling out of the playoff picture in a competitive AFC and with the hardest strength of schedule remaining, according to ESPN Analytics."

 

But under Dorsey's time as offensive coordinator, the Bills have struggled to find offensive consistency and put together drives, with 21% of drives ending in a turnover since Week 5, last in the NFL (after 12% ended in a turnover through the first four games).

 

"Buffalo's offense has not scored more than 25 points since Week 4, and turnovers have been a major issue, especially for Allen, who leads the NFL with 14 turnovers and 11 interceptions.")

 

I would hate to think of what the 2023 Buffalo Bills would have finished at if they hadn't changed OCs, or how many INTs Allen would have had, too.

 

That December 17th, 2023 game against the Dallas Cowboys was a thing of beauty to me: 49 rushes for 266 yards, 3 TDs in a 31-10 win. Meanwhile, QB Josh Allen went 7 of 15 for 94 passing yards, 1 TD.  That OC change was so impactful to the Buffalo offense and QB, in my view. 

 

Finding the right HC or OC is key to QB performance; going from Brian Daboll to Ken Dorsey, who had Allen throwing all over to Diggs, it wasn't working all that well.  Plus, simply look at Jacksonville, as Trevor Lawrence was starting to look like a bust until they hired Liam Coen as HC. This, with Lawrence having a previous SB-winning HC in Doug Pederson as HC. Conversely, look what new OC Mike McDaniel has done to Justin Herbert with the Chargers. 

 

McDermott firing Dorsey and promoting Joe Brady was a godsend to QB Josh Allen, as it helped him win MVP with 28 TDs and 6 INTs. Buffalo went 13-4 in 2024.  

Offensive Turnaround (Mid-2023): After taking over as interim offensive coordinator in November 2023 (replacing Ken Dorsey), Brady rescued a sluggish 5–5 start, leading Buffalo to an 11–6 finish, the AFC East title, and a playoff push. The Buffalo 2025 running game also took a terrific upturn, with Buffalo becoming the #1 rushing team in the NFL, with RB James Cook as the leading rusher.

 

Just my 2 cents. 

 

 

  • Like (+1) 1
  • Disagree 1
  • Agree 1
Posted
6 hours ago, SoTier said:

 

I knew that Harbaugh wasn't available, but I didn't realize that he was hired before the Bills even fired McDermott.    My example was hypothetical because many Bills fans dreamed of Harbaugh becoming the Bills HC.   That was never me.  I dislike both Harbaughs.

I get it and wasn’t trying to be snarky. I too hate the Harbaugh’s (especially Jim).
 

The Giants though are 4-2-1 playing Jameis and McCarthy for the most part. If you inserted that coaching staff here we would be winning as well (although it may not be as fun as it is now). I stand by any qualified football coach would win 10 games, in this AFC East, with Josh Allen. I have no idea who the right guy is to navigate the waters in January. I wanted Sean Payton (badly) a few years back. He’s a complete idiot but a great football coach. He would have crushed it with the Bills. 

Posted (edited)
1 hour ago, Nihilarian said:

All this talk of Josh Allen being an automatic 10+win QB is crazy talk, in my view, as we all saw in that 2023 season under Bills OC Ken Dorsey. Allen finished that 2023 season with 29 TDs, 18 INTs, and 7 fumbles.  @SoTierHe is correct in his thinking, IMHO.

 

https://www.espn.com/nfl/story/_/id/38896424/bills-offensive-coordinator-ken-dorsey-fired-sources-say

 

("But Dorsey's firing also comes as a response to a Bills team that sits at 5-5, falling out of the playoff picture in a competitive AFC and with the hardest strength of schedule remaining, according to ESPN Analytics."

 

But under Dorsey's time as offensive coordinator, the Bills have struggled to find offensive consistency and put together drives, with 21% of drives ending in a turnover since Week 5, last in the NFL (after 12% ended in a turnover through the first four games).

 

"Buffalo's offense has not scored more than 25 points since Week 4, and turnovers have been a major issue, especially for Allen, who leads the NFL with 14 turnovers and 11 interceptions.")

 

I would hate to think of what the 2023 Buffalo Bills would have finished at if they hadn't changed OCs, or how many INTs Allen would have had, too.

 

That December 17th, 2023 game against the Dallas Cowboys was a thing of beauty to me: 49 rushes for 266 yards, 3 TDs in a 31-10 win. Meanwhile, QB Josh Allen went 7 of 15 for 94 passing yards, 1 TD.  That OC change was so impactful to the Buffalo offense and QB, in my view. 

 

Finding the right HC or OC is key to QB performance; going from Brian Daboll to Ken Dorsey, who had Allen throwing all over to Diggs, it wasn't working all that well.  Plus, simply look at Jacksonville, as Trevor Lawrence was starting to look like a bust until they hired Liam Coen as HC. This, with Lawrence having a previous SB-winning HC in Doug Pederson as HC. Conversely, look what new OC Mike McDaniel has done to Justin Herbert with the Chargers. 

 

McDermott firing Dorsey and promoting Joe Brady was a godsend to QB Josh Allen, as it helped him win MVP with 28 TDs and 6 INTs. Buffalo went 13-4 in 2024.  

Offensive Turnaround (Mid-2023): After taking over as interim offensive coordinator in November 2023 (replacing Ken Dorsey), Brady rescued a sluggish 5–5 start, leading Buffalo to an 11–6 finish, the AFC East title, and a playoff push. The Buffalo 2025 running game also took a terrific upturn, with Buffalo becoming the #1 rushing team in the NFL, with RB James Cook as the leading rusher.

 

Just my 2 cents. 

 

 

He also finished the 2023 season with 11 wins. You conveniently omitted his 15 rushing TDs that year!! He scored 44 TDs and turned it over 22 times. In this year that we are nitpicking he scored 44 times. He scored twice as often as he turned it over. He finished in the top 5 for MVP.

 

There is some math behind it. The average NFL turnover is worth 1.55 points (according to AI). Let’s call TDs worth 7. You may miss an XP or 2 and offset it with 2 point conversions. That year Josh Allen generated 308 points on his scores, and gave up 34.1 points on his turnovers. That’s a net positive of 273.9 points. His TDs were worth 16.1 PPG more than his turnovers. 
 

He has literally won 10 plus every year since 2019 and 11 plus every year since 2020. They’re pretty much a lock for that again. This is Brady-like. He scores way too much to be held below that. We keep pretending it’s crazy to think anyone can get him to 10+ but so far, that’s all he’s done since becoming elite. McDermott just happened to be sitting in that chair and a bunch of different OCs running the offense. It didn’t matter who it was. Automatic

Edited by Kirby Jackson
  • Like (+1) 2
  • Disagree 1
  • Thank you (+1) 1
Posted
6 hours ago, Kirby Jackson said:

I wanted Sean Payton (badly) a few years back. He’s a complete idiot but a great football coach. He would have crushed it with the Bills. 

 

But underachieved in the post season (pretty badly) with Drew Brees.

  • Like (+1) 1
Posted
4 hours ago, GunnerBill said:

 

But underachieved in the post season (pretty badly) with Drew Brees.

Kind of. He won one and would have probably won a 2nd if not for the worst missed call in NFL History. He finished 9-8 on the playoffs in New Orleans with a title. Payton is now overachieving in Denver with Bo Nix. 

  • Agree 2
Posted
23 minutes ago, Kirby Jackson said:

Kind of. He won one and would have probably won a 2nd if not for the worst missed call in NFL History. He finished 9-8 on the playoffs in New Orleans with a title. Payton is now overachieving in Denver with Bo Nix. 

 

He lost playoff games to inferior Quarterbacks a LOT in New Orleans. And sure, the non-call on NRC was a blown call but overall his post-season record with the Saints was underachievement.

Posted
1 hour ago, GunnerBill said:

 

He lost playoff games to inferior Quarterbacks a LOT in New Orleans. And sure, the non-call on NRC was a blown call but overall his post-season record with the Saints was underachievement.

They had some losses they shouldn’t have. At the same time, they COULD easily have been 11-6 with 2 titles. He was pretty much guaranteed 10-7 with 2 Super Bowl appearances. That call flipped the narrative. I don’t think that they hit their ceiling but it wasn’t tragic. 

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Restore formatting

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...