Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted
4 hours ago, BigDingus said:

Every team makes mistakes, but this Bills team makes a LOT of mistakes.

 

Maybe that's just our identity this year. Maybe it's a lot of ugly stretches, followed by crazy bursts of offense leading us to wins. I'm happy we get a 3 score win over the Ravens, but that game was still super messy given the circumstances.

 

Even after a bye, there's just too many moments where you wonder "can they clean this up, or will it always be like this?"

 

We had 10 penalties yesterday for 87 yards. We average 8.6 penalties a game (3rd worst in the league behind the Browns & Packers). Last year, we were 8th best, averaging only 5.9 penalties a game. 

 

Sloppy turnovers (again)... both the bobbled INT + another fumble. We're currently tied for 4th most fumbles at 11, while being tied for 3rd most LOST fumbles at 6. 

 

Along with those obvious issues, yesterday also had things like Allen over-throwing a wide open Keon Coleman (poor guy gets crap for no separation, then had the most separation he's ever seen & still gets missed! 😭), multiple bad drops, sloppy throws, and just these crazy stretches of looking hopeless, followed by a huge swing in momentum.

 

Fortunately, we were playing against a 3rd string emergency QB seeing his first game time, but usually the D adds more to the mess with missed tackles & blown coverages.

 

Anyway, happy about a win, but I just don't know if this is a symptom of coaching or something else. 

 

Can you define "clean football"?  Like, what's the minimum to be a clean game?  It sounds like it's something like:

  • No fumbles
  • no INTs
  • no dropped INTs by the defense
  • no dropped passes
  • no open receivers over/underthrown
  • under 5 penalties. 

Anything else?  No 3rd or 4th and longs given up on defense?  Whatever you think it is, post it here.  Then we can go league-wide and see what percent of all games are clean.  I suspect it'll be around 10%.

 

Not trying to invalidate your point, just trying to quantify things a bit.  (And by the way, I think a lot of this sloppiness was to be expected with a rookie HC and a rookie-at-the-NFL-level DC.  Doesn't make me happy about it; just unsurprised.)

  • Like (+1) 1
  • Thank you (+1) 1
Posted
17 minutes ago, Cash said:

 

Can you define "clean football"?  Like, what's the minimum to be a clean game?  It sounds like it's something like:

  • No fumbles
  • no INTs
  • no dropped INTs by the defense
  • no dropped passes
  • no open receivers over/underthrown
  • under 5 penalties. 

Anything else?  No 3rd or 4th and longs given up on defense?  Whatever you think it is, post it here.  Then we can go league-wide and see what percent of all games are clean.  I suspect it'll be around 10%.

 

Not trying to invalidate your point, just trying to quantify things a bit.  (And by the way, I think a lot of this sloppiness was to be expected with a rookie HC and a rookie-at-the-NFL-level DC.  Doesn't make me happy about it; just unsurprised.)

No turnovers, 5 or fewer accepted penalties against. Don’t beat yourself. The other stuff if generally par for the course in any NFL game.

  • Like (+1) 2
  • Thank you (+1) 1
Posted
3 hours ago, SoCal Deek said:

I don’t see “disciplined” football coming from Joe Brady. 

...and by extension, none of the players feeling pressure to take on that responsibility either.

Posted
5 hours ago, GoBills808 said:

most people would look at a team sitting at 6-1 having yet to play to their potential as a good thing

I agree wholeheartedly, but that doesn't mean we can't yearn for them to fix things that obviously could use fixing.  A mountain climber, who fancies himself to be world class is not going to be satisfied if he manages to climb Pike's Peak when Everest is still out there. 

  • Like (+1) 1
Posted
5 minutes ago, BigAl2526 said:

I agree wholeheartedly, but that doesn't mean we can't yearn for them to fix things that obviously could use fixing.  A mountain climber, who fancies himself to be world class is not going to be satisfied if he manages to climb Pike's Peak when Everest is still out there. 

that's not exactly the analogy id use

 

more like we've been trying and failing to climb everest for the last 5+yrs...now we're taking a different path and complaining that it looks different

Posted
1 minute ago, GoBills808 said:

that's not exactly the analogy id use

 

more like we've been trying and failing to climb everest for the last 5+yrs...now we're taking a different path and complaining that it looks different

I don't think Brady's aggressiveness and McDermott's predilection for being meticulous are mutually exclusive when it comes to correctable things like pre-snap penalties and holding on to the ball.  

Posted
4 minutes ago, BigAl2526 said:

I agree wholeheartedly, but that doesn't mean we can't yearn for them to fix things that obviously could use fixing.  A mountain climber, who fancies himself to be world class is not going to be satisfied if he manages to climb Pike's Peak when Everest is still out there. 

He's also not going to be focusing on something super specific if he still lacks the ability to climb Everest all together. McD and his 10 years of tenure had his program established. He could focus on the minutia. Brady is not in the same position. He's focused on just helping the team become better climbers. Pushing the limits of the offensive playbook and supporting the defensive transformation. These guys are focused on executing assignments, not jumping Offside. Frankly, I prefer it that way. Turnovers aside, which this team shows a historical ability to overcome when working against them. Very little correlation exists to penalties and outcomes. Lots of great teams have been sloppy in this regard. Focus on making strides moving the ball and stopping teams from doing the same. Playing fast and free. Worrying about the details obsessively is part of the reason our cheeks clinched when it mattered most.    

Posted
2 minutes ago, BigAl2526 said:

I don't think Brady's aggressiveness and McDermott's predilection for being meticulous are mutually exclusive when it comes to correctable things like pre-snap penalties and holding on to the ball.  

i'd disagree

 

and i wouldnt claim to have an understanding of how their different philosophies translate into granular areas of the game but if the cost of a more aggressive philosophy is the 'sloppier' brand of football we've experienced thus far i'll gladly suffer it...some folks been asking for exactly that since 2023 in fact

Posted

As for the turnovers, we have kind of always been like this even in the McDermott era. We are just so much more talented at the most important positions that we can overcome these deficiencies against average to below average teams. Its the playoffs where it has bitten us in the ass. 

Posted

This whole season, I've been looking for things that are different than prior years that could offer some hope for why things will go differently this season.

 

But instead of seeing things that make me optimistic, I see a team that consistently steps on rakes & outright demands the offense put up 30+ ppg, otherwise they will lose. It may not have hurt us against a 3rd string QB seeing his first NFL action, and it didn't kill us when we had 5 turnovers against arguably the worst team in the league, but does anyone expect that to last in the playoffs?

 

Then today I see a graphic of teams throughout history who averaged 33+ ppg like the Bills & how their seasons ended, and this is what we got - Out of 14 teams to do it, 5 have made the SB, and ZERO have won it. 

 

Hey, making a SB would be huge in itself, so I'm excited about that one. But would it be as exciting to make a SB, only to get destroyed like the 2013 Broncos losing to the Legion of Boom Seahawks D? Not so much. 

 

I'm holding onto hope that something will click & that the team's penchant for bad decision-making & penalties slowly fades away. I just want to see Brady's team look noticeably BETTER than McDermott's... not just a more messy, incomplete version of McDermott's team. 

 

 

Bills 33 PPG.jpg

  • Thank you (+1) 1
Posted

My main worries:

 

Lack of discipline catching us in the end. It’s become a race to the finish line.

 

Ball security from our offensive skill positions, especially Kincaid. Teams are really focusing on the strip every time they have the ball. They’re seeing something in their game prep.

  • Like (+1) 1
Posted
6 hours ago, Bruffalo said:

The Bills commit penalties. It usually doesn't kill them.

 


They are saving that for the playoffs. 🫣

Posted
4 hours ago, GoBills808 said:

i'd disagree

 

and i wouldnt claim to have an understanding of how their different philosophies translate into granular areas of the game but if the cost of a more aggressive philosophy is the 'sloppier' brand of football we've experienced thus far i'll gladly suffer it...some folks been asking for exactly that since 2023 in fact

OK.  I have no problem disagreeing with someone.  We will see what the future holds.

Posted
11 hours ago, Alphadawg7 said:

Have they ever?

 

51-3 would be the "cleanest" game the Bills ever played in their history. The reality is there will be momentum swings in games. The other team will make plays as well. Mistakes will happen as the players are human. 

Posted (edited)
12 hours ago, vincec said:

No turnovers, 5 or fewer accepted penalties against. Don’t beat yourself. The other stuff if generally par for the course in any NFL game.

Only one team met that standard week 8. The raiders vs the jets. Raiders cleanly gave up 33 points.  Only 16 games so far this entire season have met the standard. Bill had one of them. So the Bills are above average by this standard.

 

 There have been 121 games (242 teams attempting this feat) so 6.6 percent of the time does this happen.  This conforms to the overall TBD concept that if the village not above the 90th percentile in every phase   the team failed despite winning the game. if we achieve this stat, we immediately shift into “but it wasn’t againt

one of the four best teams in the league, so the win should be dismissed as meaning anything.

Edited by Chaos
Posted

Perhaps you aren't familiar with the NFL in 2026. What team is playing "clean football", as you describe it, in the league this year?

  • Like (+1) 1
  • Awesome! (+1) 1

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Restore formatting

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...