Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted
4 hours ago, mannc said:

The Rams won the toss and elected to kick to the Bills, which seems to be the prevailing wisdom, with the thinking that after the receiving team's possession, the kicking team gets the ball back, knowing what they need to either win or tie the game.  Most teams who win the OT coin toss seem to be electing to kick.  I disagree with this strategy, especially in the regular season, where the OT period is limited to 10 minutes.

 

First, the receiving team can chew up the clock, maybe as much as seven or eight minutes.  If they score a TD, then the kicking team might have as little as 2:30 left by the time they get the ball, which limits the type of drive they can mount, especially if they've already used one of their two OT timeouts.  More importantly, if the receiving team doesn't score, then punts the ball to the kicking team, they know that if they get a stop, they will get the ball next with a chance to win the game with a FG.  So in essence, they have a good chance to get two possessions, while the kicking team is probably only going to get one, unless both teams go three-and-out quickly.  I think the opportunity to get an "extra" possession outweighs the advantage the kicking team gets from knowing what they need. 

 

And here's another point.  With the new kickoff rule, the receiving team is likely to get the ball at their own 35-yardline or better.  If they advance it even to their own 40, they can pin the kicking team deep in their own territory with a punt, significantly reducing the kicking team's chance of scoring.  That is exactly what happened to the Bills in the playoff game against Denver.  Even though their defense got a stop on Denver's first possession, the Bills started their only OT possession inside their own 10-yard line. To me, if we have a choice in OT, we should always elect to receive. 

 

Thoughts?

 

             


if it was first score wins or first TD wins then 90% of the time the team winning the toss would receive.  The times not is if you have a dominating defense who can get a 3 and out.

 

now with both teams having a chance you want the ball second because you know what you need to do to win with a GG, TD, or TD+2.

 

of course clock is a restriction so in theory the team getting the kick off coukd burn 9+ min on the 10 min clock and leave the other team with no time left.  How often do trans have a 9:30+ scoring drive?

Posted

No valid reason to receive now that you are guaranteed a possession. You'll always get an extra down if the other team scores versus if you get the ball first and have to punt.

  • Like (+1) 1
Posted
2 hours ago, JimBob2232 said:

I do think it's a pretty fascinating conversation. 

 

Ball 1st - Big advantage is the 2nd possession only needing a FG.    

Ball 2nd - Big advantage is knowing what you need on 1st possession.

 

Ball 2nd so you know what you need and go for two on a TD for the win might be the optimal play here.  I gotta think that long term, a FG on that 3rd OT possession will win A LOT.

This is what AI gave me.

 

Summary Table

Overtime OutcomeTotal Occurrences

1st Possession (Defensive Score)0

2nd Possession Win33

3rd Possession Win18

4th Possession or Later Win6

Ties (Neither team leads after 10 mins)5

 

Note that there were two rule changes:

2021 Season (Josh Allen Rule Change) -  Both teams get a possession.  However, if the 1st team scores a TD, the 2nd team doesn't get a possession

2025 Season - Both teams get a possession irrespective of the 1st team scoring a TD. 

 

As you mentioned the team with 2nd possession has a high rate of success -  33 wins followed by 3rd possession (giving life for the team that failed the 1st possession). 

 

I did a further check on how many teams won after scoring a TD on the 1st possession of the game:
 

Summary

Opening Drive Touchdowns (Instant Wins, 2021–2024): 15

Games where the 2nd possession team got the ball after a 1st-drive TD and failed to score: 0

 

Since2025 (Sample size is small)    We don't have a single game won on the 1st TD scored and the 2nd possession of the OT not scoring a TD.   They have always gone on to a sudden death beyond 2nd possession of OT.   Amazing

52 minutes ago, djp14150 said:


if it was first score wins or first TD wins then 90% of the time the team winning the toss would receive.  The times not is if you have a dominating defense who can get a 3 and out.

 

now with both teams having a chance you want the ball second because you know what you need to do to win with a GG, TD, or TD+2.

 

of course clock is a restriction so in theory the team getting the kick off coukd burn 9+ min on the 10 min clock and leave the other team with no time left.  How often do trans have a 9:30+ scoring drive?

On the given day, if your offense is playing lights out and the defense is struggling, would you still give up the ball to the other team on the 1st possession?   The Rams defense had been gashed in that 4th quarter and they shot themselves in the foot by asking the Bills to recevie.   What were they thinking?

 

 

Posted
2 hours ago, mannc said:

It’s not like college OT, where the number of possessions is always the same. By taking the ball first, you greatly increase your chance of getting an extra possession. And the new kickoff rule magnifies that advantage…

It is however the same in what teams are pursuing. Which is an extra down. I can reasonably assume you don’t know the value of that relative to the variables in accepting the ball first. I’m all for contrarian views, it’s just unlikely this mental exercise has not been performed many times by people with better information and bigger brains. 

Posted
2 hours ago, mannc said:

And the 4-down thing only really kicks in if the receiving team scores a TD…

 

If you're starting at your own 25 and need a FG, that 4th down can still come in really handy, imo.

  • Like (+1) 1
Posted
4 hours ago, Mikie2times said:

That is the sole reason and why you see the same approach in college. Other team scores, you have 4 downs. Extra down is pretty massive, likely nullifying any benefits being called out. In todays game it would be shocking if coaches across pro and college are on the wrong side of the data with this.  

The key difference is in college OT, you always have a “turn” to match. 
 

In nfl, after each team has a possession, first score wins. 
 

That does give a big advantage to the team that gets the third possession, which is the receiving team. 
 

I can see both sides. 
 

Ultimately, after 100 or so games have been played with current ot rules, there may be enough data to say whether receiving or kicking team wins more often. And it may take >100 games to obtain statistically significant results. With a sample size that is too small, you may run into a type 2 error. 

Posted
3 hours ago, Big Turk said:

No valid reason to receive now that you are guaranteed a possession. You'll always get an extra down if the other team scores versus if you get the ball first and have to punt.

As discussed elsewhere in this thread, there are a number of valid reasons to receive, the most important of which is getting the third possession, if there is one, of course. 

Posted
Just now, mannc said:

As discussed elsewhere in this thread, there are a number of valid reasons to receive, the most important of which is getting the third possession, if there is one, of course. 

 

Never play for a possession you might not get versus one you are guaranteed to get.

  • Thank you (+1) 1
Posted (edited)
4 minutes ago, Big Turk said:

 

Never play for a possession you might not get versus one you are guaranteed to get.

That’s not a valid argument. There is a good chance the game will come down to the third possession, just like it did in the Broncos playoff game 9 months ago. That game also showed the value of being able to pin your opponent deep in their territory with a punt if you receive the kickoff and aren’t able to score. 

Edited by mannc
Posted
Just now, mannc said:

That’s not a valid argument. There is a good chance the game will come down to the third possession, just like it did in the Broncos playoff game 9 months ago. That game also showed the value of being able to pin your opponent deep in their territory with a punt if you receive the kickoff and aren’t able to score.

 

Of course it's a valid argument. Your job is to play to win, not play tiddlywinks and hope for extra possessions.

  • Like (+1) 1
Posted

I like kicking first. You hope the opposing team has to punt, or worst case gets 3 points…. But it allows us then to use all 4 downs when we get the ball if need be. 

Posted (edited)
19 minutes ago, Big Turk said:

 

Of course it's a valid argument. Your job is to play to win, not play tiddlywinks and hope for extra possessions.

That’s not an argument…it’s a platitude. The Bills’ last two OT games have been decided on the third possession.  Not a big sample size, but it shows that the third possession matters.

 

here is some data: in the 22 OT games since the rule change, the receiving team is 13-7-2. Again, not a huge sample size, but evidence that kicking off is not the clear advantage many seem to think.  Nevertheless, in 16 of the 22 games, the team that won the toss elected to kick.

Edited by mannc
  • Like (+1) 1
Posted

Here we go again!

 

I was watching the San Jose St/Nevada game which went to OT.  Although a different game with different rules, the announcers debated whether a team should take the ball first or 2nd.  In this game, Nevada won the toss and elected to defend 1st.   San Jose St went for it on 4th and one from the 16 instead of kicking a FG.   Nevada ran the ball a few times and then won with a FG.

 

The consensus, which I think makes a lot of sense is that you defend first so you know what you have to do when it’s your turn on offense.  If the opponent kicks a FG, that’s all you need is a FG to tie but a TD can win it.

 

In the NFL, as others have mentioned, you’ve got the 10 minute time limit.   So, say a team like the Rams gets the ball first and uses those short quick passes to slowly move down the field.  They could take up say 8 minutes off the clock and score a TD, leaving the opponent only 2 minutes to go down the field to score a TD to tie or win if they go for two.

 

I, for one, thought changing the OT period from 15 minutes to 10 minutes for the reasons the NFL gave was bogus.  I’m surprised we haven’t seen more ties, especially with neither team having scored in OT.

 

Posted
12 hours ago, Wizard said:

With this Bills current offense, receive. With this Bills current defense, receive.

Totally. I’m not sure how anyone can argue with this. If I have a #1 offense and #30 defense. How is this not the right answer? The big unknown is when you are at first possession marginal kick distance—that’s a hell of a decision right there….

Posted
7 hours ago, ganesh said:

 

On the given day, if your offense is playing lights out and the defense is struggling, would you still give up the ball to the other team on the 1st possession?   The Rams defense had been gashed in that 4th quarter and they shot themselves in the foot by asking the Bills to recevie.   What were they thinking?

 

 


 

They were thinking exactly what happened -

 

1) We get a stop all we need is a FG to win

2) We get a Turnover - all we need is a FG to win*

3) If the Bills scored a FG - we have 4 downs every drive to go score a TD to win

4) If the Bills scored a TD - we have 4 downs every drive to score a TD and go for 2 to make sure the game ends there.

 

It took a blocked FG for the Bills to get the ball back a third drive.  It happens, but LA knew that by kicking they had every option available to win the game on their 2nd drive and by kicking off they had 0 options to win on their 1st drive and needed either a stop or a tie to get to the third possession.

 

  • Agree 1
Posted

I haven’t had strong feelings on the topic since the rule change. In one of the games last week, the team that got the ball first in OT had like a 7+ minute drive. As I understand it the other team is guaranteed a possession but only if there is time on the clock. They only had 2+ minutes to match. Between that and the value of a potential 3rd possession, I lean towards, having the ball first is best. 

Posted

What im really interested in is the dynamic of 

 

1st possession - TD

2nd possession TD.

 

Now, for the 2nd team, is it better to take a one-shot for a 2PT and win/lose right there - or tie it up and hope to prevent a FG.  Clock may play a factor here - but IMO this is the big question 

Posted
2 hours ago, JimBob2232 said:

What im really interested in is the dynamic of 

 

1st possession - TD

2nd possession TD.

 

Now, for the 2nd team, is it better to take a one-shot for a 2PT and win/lose right there - or tie it up and hope to prevent a FG.  Clock may play a factor here - but IMO this is the big question 

Good point.  I suspect that the team who gets the ball second is almost always going to go for the win rather than to tie it up, unless they are facing 4 and long and have to kick a FG.  You don’t want to have to kick off again, giving your opponent a chance to win. And coaches are afraid of being criticized for playing for a tie. I doubt you will ever see a team kick an extra point to tie on the second possession; they are almost forced to go for 2.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Restore formatting

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...