Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted (edited)

https://buffalonews.com/sports/professional/nfl/bills/article_504aae18-8d82-4a36-b341-729384a9599e.html?gift=1&gift_token=01681adf-2712-48aa-b484-d99d9eda3d34

 

As usual, a great read from Jim Kubiak.  Top line review:

 

"It appears, in this Brady era, that he is giving more of a load on Allen...The turnovers, combined with his late game decisions, tell us that a change in coaching strategy [is needed]... with an emphasis on proven QB management principles..."

 

Highlights:

-Brady taking the ball after winning the toss ala Detroit (note: Chargers won the toss and elected to kick so Brady did not make the choice there) defies conventional wisdom.  My take-- Brady has moved passed being aggressive to being aggressively stupid.

 

-Patriots were doing nothing exotic on defense, not a lot of exotic looks or blitzes

 

- Bills from the jump got away from running the ball.  Pass happy.  Last year they passed 45% of time, this year 50%.  Even more so v. Pats

 

-Too much Allen leads to more bad Josh plays, including muffed handoff to Cook, behind-the -back pass (pure panic and lucky to get away with it), a wide-open miss to Shakir on 3rd and 4, blown read on two-point conversion and interception to end the game.

 

Other stuff:

-Checkdown screen pass to the WR that everyone hates was actually a good call under the circumstances and would have worked but Palmer blew the block.

 

Two-point conversion play gave Allen three options. Corner pass to Coleman, pass to Palmer, and built-in TE delay. Without pressure, Allen never looked for that built-in option.

Interception at end-- Allen completely loses situational awareness.  Loses focus on ball security and clock management.

 

Bottom line for me, Brady needs to be less of Allen's pal and more parental.  He should not coddle Allen as it brings out the bad parts of Allen's game.  Kubiak concludes that if Brady does not get this team more focused on ball security and taking what is there instead of being overly aggressive, this team will not get to where it wants to go.

 

Article behind a paywall.

 

Edited by Casey D
  • Like (+1) 6
  • Agree 5
  • Awesome! (+1) 2
  • Thank you (+1) 12
Posted
2 minutes ago, PauleeeWalnuts said:

I wish they hired the other Kubiak…

He seems to be doing great things for the Raiders.

  • Like (+1) 4
Posted
2 minutes ago, PauleeeWalnuts said:

I wish they hired the other Kubiak…

The fan and media reaction to Sundays games are why the Vegas job was a better opening than Buffalo. A new coaching staff takes time, and Brady has none in Buffalo. Close losses are good in Vegas, but national tragedies in Buffalo. 

  • Like (+1) 3
  • Agree 5
  • Thank you (+1) 2
  • Dislike 1
Posted

So, what we have is Sugar High Brady. 

 

I get the idea of being aggressive. And even though I didn't like it, I understand the reason to take the ball first. Lead with strength. Problem is when you take the ball and fail to score it puts you in catch up mode right away. 

 

I get Brady being a young offensive minded coach will lead to some issues of over aggression. What we are missing is the "adult in the room". Someone to keep Brady grounded. Maybe Carmichael is that guy. Maybe he has tried and been overruled. Who knows. 

 

All in all, we knew the first part of the schedule there would be some learning on the job from both Brady and Leonhard. I think they will both figure some things out as the season goes on. 

 

Speaking of Leonhard, I think he should give moving to the box a try. I get wanting to be on the field. I get as an ex player he's probably more comfortable on the ground. But he's not seeing the field well. And whomever he has up in the box relaying information is obviously missing stuff or they have poor communication. 

  • Like (+1) 2
  • Agree 3
Posted
51 minutes ago, Casey D said:

https://buffalonews.com/sports/professional/nfl/bills/article_504aae18-8d82-4a36-b341-729384a9599e.html?gift=1&gift_token=01681adf-2712-48aa-b484-d99d9eda3d34

 

As usual, a great read from Jim Kubiak.  Top line review:

 

"It appears, in this Brady era, that he is giving more of a load on Allen...The turnovers, combined with his late game decisions, tell us that a change in coaching strategy [is needed]... with an emphasis on proven QB management principles..."

 

Highlights:

-Brady taking the ball after winning the toss ala Detroit (note: Chargers won the toss and elected to kick so Brady did not make the choice there) defies conventional wisdom.  My take-- Brady has moved passed being aggressive to being aggressively stupid.

 

-Patriots were doing nothing exotic on defense, not a lot of exotic looks or blitzes

 

- Bills from the jump got away from running the ball.  Pass happy.  Last year they passed 45% of time, this year 50%.  Even more so v. Pats

 

-Too much Allen leads to more bad Josh plays, including muffed handoff to Cook, behind-the -back pass (pure panic and lucky to get away with it), a wide-open miss to Shakir on 3rd and 4, blown read on two-point conversion and interception to end the game.

 

Other stuff:

-Checkdown screen pass to the WR that everyone hates was actually a good call under the circumstances and would have worked but Palmer blew the block.

 

Two-point conversion play gave Allen three options. Corner pass to Coleman, pass to Palmer, and built-in TE delay. Without pressure, Allen never looked for that built-in option.

Interception at end-- Allen completely loses situational awareness.  Loses focus on clock security and clock management.

 

Bottom line for me, Brady needs to be less of Allen's pal and more parental.  He should not coddle Allen as it brings out the bad parts of Allen's game.  Kubiak concludes that if Brady does not get this team more focused on ball security and taking what is there instead of being overly aggressive, this team will not get to where it wants to go.

 

Article behind a paywall.

 

 

So we're back to the Ken Dorsey/We HaVe A uNiCoRn offense?

Posted

i think there is some truth to this article, but it over plays its hand.

 

against the pats, our issues were on d, but im thinking that's not getting solved just yet, so we have to rely on the O.  we just needed cook to get more touches and runs, and kinkaid to be featured more.  if that means brady needs to stop josh audibling out of run plays (which i don't think was happnening, i think on key late drives cook wasn't even in enough, i could be wrong) or leaning on him to target kinki more (kinki ran like 17 routes, that's just not enough, he's our best weapon, and doubly so when moore is hurt) then it's a tough love solution.

 

i think if he just figured the above out sooner in the game, we'd have had a 3 or 4 point lead when we got the ball late, and it likely woulda been on the back of another onside kick, and we just waltz to the victory formation.

ill add -- we were super sugar high josh with dorsey, including the season where the cinci game was cancelled and we lost a total of 3 games by 8 total points all season (22).  the next year it was really falling apart (altho the d and special teams were the real culprit, but the solution was always better o) and brady came in a made us a running powerhouse, brady can do this.

  • Like (+1) 1
Posted
9 minutes ago, Low Positive said:

The fan and media reaction to Sundays games are why the Vegas job was a better opening than Buffalo. A new coaching staff takes time, and Brady has none in Buffalo. Close losses are good in Vegas, but national tragedies in Buffalo. 

I’m going to assume you know what the difference between the Bills and Raiders in terms of expectations, rosters and current team point of development.  Right?

  • Like (+1) 1
Posted
11 minutes ago, Low Positive said:

The fan and media reaction to Sundays games are why the Vegas job was a better opening than Buffalo. A new coaching staff takes time, and Brady has none in Buffalo. Close losses are good in Vegas, but national tragedies in Buffalo. 


Eh.. high risk/high reward. 
 

Is Kubiak ever finding glory in Vegas?  Maybe.. not likely. 
 

This pressure cooker could make anyone a one and done, two and out… but if you win the Super Bowl here, you’re a legend, perhaps to the extent few coaches ever feel. 

  • Like (+1) 1
  • Awesome! (+1) 1
  • Thank you (+1) 1
Posted
57 minutes ago, Casey D said:

.

 

Bottom line for me, Brady needs to be less of Allen's pal and more parental.  He should not coddle Allen as it brings out the bad parts of Allen's game.  Kubiak concludes that if Brady does not get this team more focused on ball security and taking what is there instead of being overly aggressive, this team will not get to where it wants to go.

 

Article behind a paywall.

 

Very good points. It should now become obvious that "unleash Josh" will never be a thing. We should actually wish for controlled Josh. 

  • Agree 1
Posted (edited)

I disagree with him to a certain extent in that we went into the year wanting to be more aggressive passing because we have DJ Moore. And, last year (and when Moore goes out) it was a slog to move the ball. Don't want to go back to last year, but we have gotten away from the run twice now when DJ went down.

 

The bizarro decisions and the lack of ball security I agree with. Josh, Cook and the others need to have their asses chewed for that. Has anybody else noticed we keep getting fumbles caused by guys coming from behind and the ball is out away from the body? I keep hearing excuses for those plays and I can tell you from experience its BS. That can and should be corrected.

Edited by D. L. Hot-Flamethrower
  • Like (+1) 4
Posted
3 minutes ago, colin said:

i think there is some truth to this article, but it over plays its hand.

 

against the pats, our issues were on d, but im thinking that's not getting solved just yet, so we have to rely on the O.  we just needed cook to get more touches and runs, and kinkaid to be featured more.  if that means brady needs to stop josh audibling out of run plays (which i don't think was happnening, i think on key late drives cook wasn't even in enough, i could be wrong) or leaning on him to target kinki more (kinki ran like 17 routes, that's just not enough, he's our best weapon, and doubly so when moore is hurt) then it's a tough love solution.

 

i think if he just figured the above out sooner in the game, we'd have had a 3 or 4 point lead when we got the ball late, and it likely woulda been on the back of another onside kick, and we just waltz to the victory formation.

ill add -- we were super sugar high josh with dorsey, including the season where the cinci game was cancelled and we lost a total of 3 games by 8 total points all season (22).  the next year it was really falling apart (altho the d and special teams were the real culprit, but the solution was always better o) and brady came in a made us a running powerhouse, brady can do this.

Re: Kincaid, here's Joe B's All-22 analysis from The Athletic:

 

"Over the last two games, Kincaid’s usage has fallen off a cliff. His YPRR in Weeks 3 and 4 dropped to 1.13, and his target rate is an alarming 12.5 percent. Over that span, his YPRR ranks 122nd of 209 qualifying running backs, wide receivers and tight ends who ran at least 20 routes. The target rate is tied for 160th of that same qualifying group of 209 players.

 

So what happened? The film shows teams’ different approaches to defending Kincaid based on their personnel. The Chargers had the super versatile Derwin James. Even though James turned 30 this summer, he still moved around extremely well when matching up against Kincaid as often as he did. The Chargers also gave him some cloud coverage over the top, making Josh Allen look elsewhere. Kincaid did get free on a long run after the catch, which ultimately ended in a lost fumble. Outside of that play, his only other catch was for 14 yards.

 

Then came the Patriots, who took a different approach against Kincaid. The context is also a bit different, given that DJ Moore left the game early with a shoulder injury, which heightened attention on Kincaid. The Bills — and their opponents — know how important Kincaid is to their offense. With due respect to their other boundary receivers and slot receiver Khalil Shakir, the Patriots clearly showed that halting Kincaid’s production and forcing the other pass catchers to step up was the most important part of their plan.

 

Like the Chargers, the Patriots provided help over the top, forcing Allen to go elsewhere, but New England didn’t have someone like James. Instead, the Patriots wanted Kincaid to prove he could handle physicality before running his route. New England gave him plenty of shoves and chips within five yards to reroute him, and there were a handful of times it knocked him off course, messed up the timing of the route, and even caused a stumble or two. Kincaid also had a handful of first reads that never got the ball delivered his way because of the Patriots’ coverage.

 

While the Chargers’ James-led approach wasn’t sticky, the Patriots tested his physicality, which they will certainly see again with Kincaid playing this well. Physicality is where Kincaid tends to struggle. His lack of blocking skills is a problem at times, and it was a big issue against the Patriots, so it was smart of them to transfer those physicality concerns over to the passing game. It wasn’t every snap. It was just enough to make him uncomfortable and think it could be coming. That attention grew when Moore left the game, which made the issue worse."

 

https://www.nytimes.com/athletic/7666660/2026/10/07/bills-film-review-dalton-kincaid-josh-allen/

 

  • Like (+1) 5
  • Thank you (+1) 3
Posted
6 minutes ago, SCBills said:


Eh.. high risk/high reward. 
 

Is Kubiak ever finding glory in Vegas?  Maybe.. not likely. 
 

This pressure cooker could make anyone a one and done, two and out… but if you win the Super Bowl here, you’re a legend, perhaps to the extent few coaches ever feel. 

Vegas was the best opening last cycle. They already had Bowers, Jenty, and some young pieces on defenses. They had the #1 pick to take a QB, and mountains of cap space to rebuild the OL and bring in Cousins as a bridge. They also have a fanbase and owner  that would be happy with 9-8 in the first year. if I were a coordinator ready for my promotion, that’s the situation I’d be looking for. The Jets are going to be the prime job this cycle, with young talent, oodles of picks, mountains of cap space, and a fanbase happy with 9-8. The Bills, on the other hand, have fans that aren’t satisfied with yearly playoff wins, no space, an old roster, and no premium picks. Hence Kubiak not even being interviewed and the internal promotions. 

 

Raiders fans are happy as clams today. Their defense gave up 177 yards rushing. Think about that. 

11 minutes ago, dave mcbride said:

Re: Kincaid, here's Joe B's All-22 analysis from The Athletic:

 

"Over the last two games, Kincaid’s usage has fallen off a cliff. His YPRR in Weeks 3 and 4 dropped to 1.13, and his target rate is an alarming 12.5 percent. Over that span, his YPRR ranks 122nd of 209 qualifying running backs, wide receivers and tight ends who ran at least 20 routes. The target rate is tied for 160th of that same qualifying group of 209 players.

 

So what happened? The film shows teams’ different approaches to defending Kincaid based on their personnel. The Chargers had the super versatile Derwin James. Even though James turned 30 this summer, he still moved around extremely well when matching up against Kincaid as often as he did. The Chargers also gave him some cloud coverage over the top, making Josh Allen look elsewhere. Kincaid did get free on a long run after the catch, which ultimately ended in a lost fumble. Outside of that play, his only other catch was for 14 yards.

 

Then came the Patriots, who took a different approach against Kincaid. The context is also a bit different, given that DJ Moore left the game early with a shoulder injury, which heightened attention on Kincaid. The Bills — and their opponents — know how important Kincaid is to their offense. With due respect to their other boundary receivers and slot receiver Khalil Shakir, the Patriots clearly showed that halting Kincaid’s production and forcing the other pass catchers to step up was the most important part of their plan.

 

Like the Chargers, the Patriots provided help over the top, forcing Allen to go elsewhere, but New England didn’t have someone like James. Instead, the Patriots wanted Kincaid to prove he could handle physicality before running his route. New England gave him plenty of shoves and chips within five yards to reroute him, and there were a handful of times it knocked him off course, messed up the timing of the route, and even caused a stumble or two. Kincaid also had a handful of first reads that never got the ball delivered his way because of the Patriots’ coverage.

 

While the Chargers’ James-led approach wasn’t sticky, the Patriots tested his physicality, which they will certainly see again with Kincaid playing this well. Physicality is where Kincaid tends to struggle. His lack of blocking skills is a problem at times, and it was a big issue against the Patriots, so it was smart of them to transfer those physicality concerns over to the passing game. It wasn’t every snap. It was just enough to make him uncomfortable and think it could be coming. That attention grew when Moore left the game, which made the issue worse."

 

https://www.nytimes.com/athletic/7666660/2026/10/07/bills-film-review-dalton-kincaid-josh-allen/

 

Thanks for that. It’s exactly what I saw, and what the Bills will see from now on. Kincaid is like Xavier Worthy; bring up a defender and bump them before their release, and all their advantages as a player disappear.

  • Disagree 1
Posted

Nick Wright famously said “the Bills offense works better when Allen throws the ball less.” Probably the same can be said of all QBs in this modern NFL era though. All except for maybe Stafford.

Posted

Jerry O on Locked On Bills said something that I think was spot on: 

 

He mentioned how we've been critical of Allen in the past for his 'arm arrogance' in thinking he can make every throw.

 

Brady seems to have a bit of "Josh Allen Arrogance" thinking he can continually make aggressive decisions because he has Josh. 

  • Like (+1) 5
  • Awesome! (+1) 1
Posted (edited)

Allen deserves the criticism, but I do not care about the desperate pass out of the end zone to avoid a safety. It actually worked, so I give Allen credit. Could it have gone wrong? Absolutely. But that's the case on every play. Every incompletion could have been an INT. I don't think it was an amazing decision, but being backed up up in your own end zone usually leads to QBs struggling under pressure, not just Allen. Avoiding the safety there was a good outcome.

 

The interceptions and missing open receivers was worse. Abandoning the run game (coaching) was worse. Abandoning the great strategy of moving the pocket around used week 1 (coaching) was worse. Abandoning play action (coaching) was worse. Not targeting or scheming up opportunities for Kincaid, arguably the best offensive passing weapon on the team, was worse. And that's just the offense. There are so many worse things to nitpick about. Getting the ball off for an incompletion avoiding a safety isn't even a blip on the radar for me.

Edited by MJS
  • Like (+1) 5
Posted
1 hour ago, Casey D said:

 

- Bills from the jump got away from running the ball.  Pass happy.  Last year they passed 45% of time, this year 50%.  Even more so v. Pats

 

Maybe football is different but going from 45% to 50% doesn't seem like a huge leap and deserving of the label "pass happy".

 

 

  • Agree 2
Posted
15 minutes ago, Low Positive said:

Vegas was the best opening last cycle. They already had Bowers, Jenty, and some young pieces on defenses. They had the #1 pick to take a QB, and mountains of cap space to rebuild the OL and bring in Cousins as a bridge. They also have a fanbase and owner  that would be happy with 9-8 in the first year. if I were a coordinator ready for my promotion, that’s the situation I’d be looking for. The Jets are going to be the prime job this cycle, with young talent, oodles of picks, mountains of cap space, and a fanbase happy with 9-8. The Bills, on the other hand, have fans that aren’t satisfied with yearly playoff wins, no space, an old roster, and no premium picks. Hence Kubiak not even being interviewed and the internal promotions. 

 

Raiders fans are happy as clams today. Their defense gave up 177 yards rushing. Think about that. 

Thanks for that. It’s exactly what I saw, and what the Bills will see from now on. Kincaid is like Xavier Worthy; bring up a defender and bump them before their release, and all their advantages as a player disappear.

YOU THINK UPCOMING COOORDINATORS AND COACHES DONT HEAR ABOUT HOW WOODY ALLEN RUNS HIS FRANCHISE?  ZERO CHANCE THEY GET A TOP CANDIDATE

  • Like (+1) 1
  • Haha (+1) 1
Posted
5 minutes ago, BuffaloRebound said:

Is Brady capable of being parental with this group when it was mcdermott who wore the pants?  

 

A different era/time period but one coach who could really get on his players if they messed up was Parcells. I remember listening to Simms in interviews and he recalled so many shouting matches with him if he screwed up. Parcells wasn't shy about calling players out and ripping them a new one in front of everybody on the sidelines during games, at practice, or even in team meetings. But that style worked as he was a very successful coach who won two Super Bowls with the Giants. I doubt that would work with today's athletes.

  • Agree 1

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Restore formatting

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...