NoSaint Posted October 5 Posted October 5 (edited) https://www.sharpfootballanalysis.com/analysis/nfl-penalties-2026/ Quote The 17 penalties per game were the most we've ever seen in a single week after September since 2005. That's over TWO DECADES AGO! We've seen the most offensive penalties per game (7.64) in the first four weeks of a season since 2003. That's over TWO DECADES AGO! Offensive holding calls are the highest they have been at this point in a season since 2019. Offensive EPA lost due to penalties is the highest since 2005. Quote Through four weeks, an incredible 17 touchdowns have been nullified by penalty. Through four weeks in 2025, that number was just 5. It was only 4 in 2024. Over the prior decade, the average was only 8.3 touchdowns nullified by penalty. We're at a record-high 17 nullified touchdowns, more than double the prior decade's average. if you feel like the zebras are being incredibly impactful this year…. i feel like I’ve used the phrase “I guess by letter of the rule but that act didn’t impact the play and the flag drastically swayed the game” more than ever this year. Edited October 5 by NoSaint 3 2 Quote
BarleyNY Posted October 5 Posted October 5 Perhaps the reduced training camp time, less contact practices and fewer preseason games are catching up with the league. Idk if that’s it or not, but I’ve been wondering about the reasons the league is so sloppy this year. I have bought NFL Premium+ for years. I usually watch almost all of the NFL games (that I don’t see live) on condensed format. That tails off during the year, especially after injuries take their toll on teams and QBs. But early on I like to take stock of new players and coaches and just generally see how teams look. This year I tried, but it’s brutal. I just can’t do it. It isn’t fun. The penalties are a big part of it - and they are being committed on way too many plays. The refs get a lot of heat - and they are far from perfect - but it’s a very sloppy league in general right now. I’ve never seen this before. It is tough to watch because overall the NFL’s product has taken a nosedive. I can only hope that teams round into shape and it gets a lot better because as of today I’d say the NCAA has a much better product. 2 1 Quote
Dablitzkrieg Posted October 5 Posted October 5 Have refs ever been suspended before today? I don't recall Quote
machine gun kelly Posted October 5 Posted October 5 Jeremy on the morning show will love this will all of his rants on Gene Steretore (not sure on spelling and don’t care). Quote
HardyBoy Posted October 6 Posted October 6 Or maybe they are trying to enforce rules in different ways for whatever reason and players are still getting used to what they can get away with? I'm sure the league mentioned something was going to be a point of emphasis and players need to adjust...hopefully, I bet we see penalties drop as players and teams adjust their tactics over the course of the year (that's my hope) Quote
T.E. Posted October 6 Posted October 6 It seems like too many of them think they are the actual show, rather than the teams. 1 4 1 1 Quote
NoSaint Posted October 6 Author Posted October 6 (edited) 31 minutes ago, BarleyNY said: Perhaps the reduced training camp time, less contact practices and fewer preseason games are catching up with the league. Idk if that’s it or not, but I’ve been wondering about the reasons the league is so sloppy this year. I have bought NFL Premium+ for years. I usually watch almost all of the NFL games (that I don’t see live) on condensed format. That tails off during the year, especially after injuries take their toll on teams and QBs. But early on I like to take stock of new players and coaches and just generally see how teams look. This year I tried, but it’s brutal. I just can’t do it. It isn’t fun. The penalties are a big part of it - and they are being committed on way too many plays. The refs get a lot of heat - and they are far from perfect - but it’s a very sloppy league in general right now. I’ve never seen this before. It is tough to watch because overall the NFL’s product has taken a nosedive. I can only hope that teams round into shape and it gets a lot better because as of today I’d say the NCAA has a much better product. is the play sloppier or the calls simply tighter? For instance, I asked at one point yesterday if the announcers addressed Josh’s injury several times would fans see his play and the offense differently? taking 17(!) touchdowns off the board through 4 weeks. How does that happen, when the last two years had 5 and 4? Did the players change that much or did the refs shift? If announcers could reasonably question the nfl your perception of the players would be higher, is my scenic point. Edited October 6 by NoSaint 1 1 Quote
BarleyNY Posted October 6 Posted October 6 1 minute ago, T.E. said: It seems like too many of them think they are the actual show, rather than the teams. I think, in general, the league likes the element of suspense that a flag brings. If we want less, do we actually need to see the refs announce penalties? How about a quick scroll across the screen while the booth tells us about it like they do anyway? Quote
Buffalo Boy Posted October 6 Posted October 6 It is slightly comforting to know it isn’t just our games. It has been brutal! Quote
Big Blitz Posted October 6 Posted October 6 Come January it’s 5 total penalties a game. It’s such a joke. 1 Quote
0017 Posted October 6 Posted October 6 (edited) The Bronco Rams game was ruined by the Refs! Shouldn’t happen…..it just seems like they want to be part of the season storyline….or at least what everyone is talking about on Mondays…a bunch of wanna be athlete nerds who definitely got bullied in high school…..makes me sick!! Edited October 6 by 0017 Quote
BarleyNY Posted October 6 Posted October 6 (edited) 8 minutes ago, NoSaint said: is the play sloppier or the calls simply tighter? For instance, I asked at one point yesterday if the announcers addressed Josh’s injury several times would fans see his play and the offense differently? taking 17(!) touchdowns off the board through 4 weeks. How does that happen, when the last two years had 5 and 4? Did the players change that much or did the refs shift? If announcers could reasonably question the nfl your perception of the players would be higher, is my scenic point. It seems sloppy in general. More mistakes of all kinds. Missed blocks, blown coverages, bad snaps, wrong routes, QB and RB go opposite ways on hand off, penalties, etc. It all happens every season to some degree, but it just seems noticeably worse this season. Just the amount of penalties from false starts and teams lining up illegally are ridiculous. That doesn’t mean that refs aren’t calling games closer. That certainly could be contributing. Edited October 6 by BarleyNY 1 Quote
SinceThe70s Posted October 6 Posted October 6 1 hour ago, NoSaint said: https://www.sharpfootballanalysis.com/analysis/nfl-penalties-2026/ if you feel like the zebras are being incredibly impactful this year…. i feel like I’ve used the phrase “I guess by letter of the rule but that act didn’t impact the play and the flag drastically swayed the game” more than ever this year. The zebras are in a damned if you do damned if you don't spot. Hi-res slo-mo replay has made it tougher, but imo the real problem is the fan base expectation of a "just" outcome that will never be agreed on. I think the NFL loves that. 1 1 Quote
Dan Posted October 6 Posted October 6 The league is in bed with multiple gambling outfits. It’s to believe that there is no influence being made during games to influence betting and payouts. 3 1 4 3 2 Quote
Buffalo ill Posted October 6 Posted October 6 Sports entertainment league. Eventually players will get penalties for rolling their eyes at a ref. Quote
mmmfriedchicken Posted October 6 Posted October 6 8 hours ago, BarleyNY said: Perhaps the reduced training camp time, less contact practices and fewer preseason games are catching up with the league. Idk if that’s it or not, but I’ve been wondering about the reasons the league is so sloppy this year. I have bought NFL Premium+ for years. I usually watch almost all of the NFL games (that I don’t see live) on condensed format. That tails off during the year, especially after injuries take their toll on teams and QBs. But early on I like to take stock of new players and coaches and just generally see how teams look. This year I tried, but it’s brutal. I just can’t do it. It isn’t fun. The penalties are a big part of it - and they are being committed on way too many plays. The refs get a lot of heat - and they are far from perfect - but it’s a very sloppy league in general right now. I’ve never seen this before. It is tough to watch because overall the NFL’s product has taken a nosedive. I can only hope that teams round into shape and it gets a lot better because as of today I’d say the NCAA has a much better product. Tbh i was just thinking this today. Im not a college guy at all; always been an nfl day but i find myself enjoying the big ncaaf matchups more outside of bills games for that very reason league is way overofficiated and sloppy at the same time… coaches with egos trying to convert 4th n 20 and 4th n 7ths instead of taking 3 pts and stuff — the coaching has been sloppy as well 2 Quote
dave mcbride Posted October 6 Posted October 6 12 hours ago, NoSaint said: https://www.sharpfootballanalysis.com/analysis/nfl-penalties-2026/ if you feel like the zebras are being incredibly impactful this year…. i feel like I’ve used the phrase “I guess by letter of the rule but that act didn’t impact the play and the flag drastically swayed the game” more than ever this year. Thanks for this. This is exactly how it has felt to me. Way, way more flags than usual. Hate it. Quote
NoSaint Posted October 6 Author Posted October 6 35 minutes ago, dave mcbride said: Thanks for this. This is exactly how it has felt to me. Way, way more flags than usual. Hate it. just no flow to games and feels like so many major moments are running the clunkiest 2 Quote
Simon Posted October 6 Posted October 6 13 hours ago, BarleyNY said: I think, in general, the league likes the element of suspense that a flag brings. I've felt for a very long time that there's a group of empty suits somewhere in the NFL front office that view officiating/replay as a way to create fake manufactured drama, mostly for people who aren't really football fans, in a misguided attempt to increase viewership. All they have been accomplishing is putting a massive crimp in the actual drama that is inherent in the game by subjecting everybody to pointless play stoppages that accomplish nothing but destroying the natural flow and dragging any rising tension to a screeching halt. What they don't seem to understand is that this is a self-defeating long term strategy, because those not-really fans will inevitably quit watching when their adopted teams are not contenders and the people that actually love the game are also going to quit watching because these jackasses have made it unwatchable by replacing real drama with fake drama. How many times did that awful game on Sunday come to a needless stop that wrecked the flow for something that wasn't even a penalty? A half-dozen? At least two of which literally changed the scoreboard? I've reached the point where I know that when the Bills are no longer SB contenders, I'm simply going to tune out. I'm not going to waste my Sunday afternoons watching referees play make-believe for the cameras; I've got better things to do with my time. And I'd bet dollars to doughnuts that I'm not the only one that feels that way. 7 2 2 Quote
BarleyNY Posted October 6 Posted October 6 Just now, Simon said: I've felt for a very long time that there's a group of empty suits somewhere in the NFL front office that view officiating/replay as a way to create fake manufactured drama, mostly for people who aren't really football fans, in a misguided attempt to increase viewership. All they have been accomplishing is putting a massive crimp in the actual drama that is inherent in the game by subjecting everybody to pointless play stoppages that accomplish nothing but destroying the natural flow and dragging any rising tension to a screeching halt. What they don't seem to understand is that this is a self-defeating long term strategy, because those not-really fans will inevitably quit watching when their adopted teams are not contenders and the people that actually love the game are also going to quit watching because these jackasses have made it unwatchable by replacing real drama with fake drama. How many times did that awful game on Sunday come to a needless stop that wrecked the flow for something that wasn't even a penalty? A half-dozen? At least two of which literally changed the scoreboard? I've reached the point where I know that when the Bills are no longer SB contenders, I'm simply going to tune out. I'm not going to waste my Sunday afternoons watching referees play make-believe for the cameras; I've got better things to do with my time. And I'd bet dollars to doughnuts that I'm not the only one that feels that way. It does feel like we are at Jump The Shark moment with the NFL. 5 Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.