Add a Good Not Great Player to Our Current Squad

[The Real Buffalo Joe]

Excluding Legends, you can bring back any player from the Bills, in his prime with us. But he has to be:

 

5 years retired from football (theoretically HOF eligible)

 

Not in the Pro Football Hall of Fame 

 

Not on the Bills wall of Fame. 

 

My initial answer was Kyle Williams. But I feel that it's only a matter of time before his name goes up on the wall. 

 

 

[Kirby Jackson]

Eric Moulds 

[Buffalo716]

Biscuit for the pass rush 

[BullBuchanan]

Jairus Byrd

[GoBills808]

dareus

[nuklz2594]

bryce paup

Phil hansen

Aaron schobel

ken davis

don beebe

[Pete]

Lorenzo Alexander 

 

Lee Evans

 

Jerry Hughes 

 

[Dave_Bills]

4 minutes ago, BullBuchanan said:

Jairus Byrd

Byrd was awesome

[Gregg]

On offense it would be Eric Moulds to give Josh another weapon and upgrade the WR room.

On defense it would be Cornelius Bennett to improve the pass rush.

 

If I were allowed to select Bills legends which your post says isn't allowed then it would be 78 and 83.

Edited Wednesday at 07:47 PM by Gregg

[BullBuchanan]

2 minutes ago, Dave_Bills said:

Byrd was awesome

His rookie year he was. He and Kiko are on my all-rookie class.

Edited Wednesday at 07:49 PM by BullBuchanan

[stlbills13]

Sean McDermott. Just kidding

 

This is a fun question. Probably Moulds on offense just because you're obviously not taking a QB. Cook is coming off a rushing title and two monster seasons so you're content at RB unless you just want to run wild. The o-line could use upgrading but there's not an absolute must-have from the past. So just kind of leaves WR and I'll go Moulds.

 

Defensively I just don't know yet since I am not sure yet where the weakness is. But you can never have enough pass rushers so any of the names mentioned already would suffice. He's not retired but if I got them in their prime you would talk me into Tre White or Matt Milano from a recency bias standpoint. 

[JP51]

TKO

[Gregg]

Even though he is known for his time with the Lions another former Bill selected for this thread could be Chris Spielman. 

[Bongo]

Mr. Ted Washington

[Buffalo716]

11 minutes ago, stlbills13 said:

Sean McDermott. Just kidding

 

This is a fun question. Probably Moulds on offense just because you're obviously not taking a QB. Cook is coming off a rushing title and two monster seasons so you're content at RB unless you just want to run wild. The o-line could use upgrading but there's not an absolute must-have from the past. So just kind of leaves WR and I'll go Moulds.

 

Defensively I just don't know yet since I am not sure yet where the weakness is. But you can never have enough pass rushers so any of the names mentioned already would suffice. He's not retired but if I got them in their prime you would talk me into Tre White or Matt Milano from a recency bias standpoint. 

I mean Ruben brown or Jason Peters would instantly upgrade us to the best line in the NFL 

 

We can have the best bookend tackles or a supreme guard next to our two good tackles already with our good center 

 

It wouldn't be my first choice but those two guys would absolutely help our offense immensely

[BigPappaPump]

Shane Conlan

Bryce Paup

Eric Moulds

Fred Jackson

[BillsPride12]

Moulds and Cornelius are the easy answers but I would probably quantify them as better than just "Good" players in my book. 

[mushypeaches]

Stevie Johnson could have a lot of fun playing with Josh Allen

[NewEra]

Offense -Moulds

 

Defense-  Takeo/Pat William would be the best fits considering the current roster but improving the pass rush should always be priority #1-  I’ll take Mario Williams.  

 

[boyst]

1 hour ago, Kirby Jackson said:

Eric Moulds 

I'd argue he was great. Criminally underrated. He did himself in with making himself over for his size and stature but the guy was as good as any WR in the game during his prime.