12/28/25 GAMEDAY Playoff bound Bills vs Eagles 4:25 pm National Feed Post Game THREAD

[dma0034]

You mean going for two?

 

Play was there and Allen missed. Bills now get a bye week

[Chugga]

I would say the dumbest decision was not cutting a kicker who couldn’t hit extra points last week and then act surprised when he can’t hit one this week that totally alters the ending and outcome of the game

[strive_for_five_guy]

No

[Einstein]

Just now, BBills said:

Why are we losing games chasing points? Fire McD !!

 

It was the right choice 

[popcornpam]

Just now, tigerthelion said:

Did you see the first kick by Badgley?

Well, after he missed the one last week, he should’ve been cut

[MikePJ76]

Just now, Iverwig said:

Josh cannot miss a throw like that in that moment. 

he had two free rushers a step from him.  He couldn't set his feet and throw it accurately.  

 

This place loves to hate on the guy.  Its baffling to me.  

[Buddy Hix]

Just a pathetic two weeks from Allen. This team is one and done in the WC.

 

For as talented as Allen is, he always loses, just can’t come up clutch.

[Nitro]

Just now, stevewin said:

All because idiot kicker missed an XP

Missed?  Blocked.  The center-guard gap was not secured. The DT got to the ball.  Nothing the kicker could do.

[Billz4ever]

Just now, boco357 said:

You trust the kicker to make a kick?

Make an XP?  Yes.  He shouldn't even be on the roster if he can't.  Ray Davis can kick an XP.

[Jerboski]

Love Josh but he was bad today 

 

this team really struggles on offense if they can’t run the ball, the receivers aren’t good enough and Josh presses 

[BillsFanForever19]

1 minute ago, BuffaloBill said:

If they kicked the fg!!!

 

Badgley is a joke. No guarantee he'd have hit it. Even from where we were.

[thenorthremembers]

No.  The kicker stinks.  Josh has to make the throw.  They beat themselves and it wasn't on coaching 

[SirAndrew]

Just now, Iverwig said:

Josh cannot miss a throw like that in that moment. 

I’m the biggest Allen fanboy, but that throw summed up why we haven’t seen a title yet. Allen is spectacular, but he’s often needed just one more play in the biggest moments, but it hasn’t worked out. 

[bigduke6]

glad to see the D have a good game for once.  id much rather have the game in the hands of JA17 than a kicker who just got one blocked.

Edited December 29, 2025 by bigduke6

[Blank Stare]

Never should’ve brought badgely into this game after last week. Cost us the game. 

[Herc11]

No, given the stakes of win or losing that game. I'm sure he didn't want to grind out OT, wearing down players even more late in the season and risking more injury. Especially in a game that was so physical 

[Einstein]

1 minute ago, SoonerBillsFan said:

Christ,  so many short passes amd wide opens missed by Allen this  year.

 

Looks like 3 road games at this point,and McDermott sucks in toad playoff games

 

You are being ridiculous. Allen has played MVP level this year.

 

 

[Ethan in Cleveland]

Just now, BBills said:

Why are we losing games chasing points? Fire McD !!

Lol...there are so many reasons to fire McDermott...going for two is not one of them...

[Kelly No huddle]

Tough loss but buffalo should get to the Superbowl with this AFC 

 

Rest everyone next week 

 

I do believe that was a Superbowl preview 

 

This will sting a little but it will be good for them 

[Heavy Kevi]

Bash if you want but going for 2 is the wrong call, considering Philly couldn't move the ball at all and we had been.

 

It's a scaredy cat move. We'd likely win that game in OT since the Eagles hadn't done anything since the 2nd quarter.