HappyDays Posted December 19, 2025 Posted December 19, 2025 If the Seahawks or 49ers win out, the Rams will be a wildcard team. And those two play each other in the final week so good chance of it happening. I'm not sure what happens if Allen and Stafford both end up as wildcards. 2 Quote
billieve420 Posted December 19, 2025 Posted December 19, 2025 (edited) 3 minutes ago, HappyDays said: If the Seahawks or 49ers win out, the Rams will be a wildcard team. And those two play each other in the final week so good chance of it happening. I'm not sure what happens if Allen and Stafford both end up as wildcards. Allen needs to win out and put up some big time numbers starting this weekend against a solid Cleveland defense. I think with Allen winning it last year will need to go above and beyond this year to beat Stafford who has this year’s MVP storyline narrative. Edited December 19, 2025 by billieve420 Quote
gobills404 Posted December 19, 2025 Posted December 19, 2025 Stafford is gonna win with better stats thanks to playing in a dome with Puka and Adams. Still no doubt in my mind 17 is the best player in the league. 1 1 Quote
Buffalo Ballin Posted December 19, 2025 Posted December 19, 2025 An L is an L. Matthew Stafford had a few chances to ice the game. He didn't do it. Quote
Billsfanatic8989 Posted December 19, 2025 Posted December 19, 2025 Take Stafford off LA and they still get to 6-7 wins. Maybe more with McVay. The Bills are drafting in the top 5 without Allen. I don't think that is an exaggeration. Like it's a pretty bad team without him. Allen is more valuable to his team. Ultimately, it's a numbers award. At least normally. And stories play a factor. Allen won last year. Stafford has sexy numbers. An MVP secures Stafford's place as a HOF QB. Stafford will win. But Allen is more valuable/clutch imo. 1 Quote
Buffalo Ballin Posted December 19, 2025 Posted December 19, 2025 Y'all acting like Josh Allen doesn't have numbers to back up his case. He sure does. Please keep in mind that the season is not over yet. 1 Quote
strive_for_five_guy Posted December 19, 2025 Posted December 19, 2025 At one point during the game, Stafford’s MVP odds on BetMGM were -800, with Maye’s at +600 and Josh at +1500. Odds are now Stafford at -210, Maye at +300 and Josh at +425. I don’t think this thing is over yet. 1 Quote
The Wiz Posted December 19, 2025 Posted December 19, 2025 (edited) 18 minutes ago, gobills404 said: Stafford is gonna win with better stats thanks to playing in a dome with Puka and Adams. Still no doubt in my mind 17 is the best player in the league. I'm not gonna argue it. He got out of detroit for a reason and he went where they realized his talent. I wouldn't be surprised if Allen realizes it at the same time that they have done him no favors with what he can do other than putting on a cape and taking over the game. Eventually he will just say, no. I'm done with this. And do the same thing as Stafford because he wants a championship instead of winning by "tightening up on defense" at the end of a game. Edited December 19, 2025 by The Wiz Quote
Billsfanatic8989 Posted December 19, 2025 Posted December 19, 2025 Maye does not deserve to be in the MVP conversation. Allen vs Stafford. That's it imo. 1 Quote
The Wiz Posted December 19, 2025 Posted December 19, 2025 (edited) 9 minutes ago, Billsfanatic8989 said: Maye does not deserve to be in the MVP conversation. Allen vs Stafford. That's it imo. If we are to believe the criteria of MVP from last year. Stafford doesn't even count. It would be Allen and Maye IMO. The player that wins and does it with the least is what MVP is to me. That's very loosely what they are trying to make it. And Honestly, it should be. Garrett should win DPOY hands down but if they were a wildcard team at 10-6, I get the feeling his odds would be pretty high to win since it's a hell of a lot easier to throw TD's than it is to get sacks. Edited December 19, 2025 by The Wiz Quote
GoBills! Posted December 19, 2025 Posted December 19, 2025 29 minutes ago, Billsfanatic8989 said: Take Stafford off LA and they still get to 6-7 wins. Maybe more with McVay. The Bills are drafting in the top 5 without Allen. I don't think that is an exaggeration. Like it's a pretty bad team without him. Allen is more valuable to his team. Ultimately, it's a numbers award. At least normally. And stories play a factor. Allen won last year. Stafford has sexy numbers. An MVP secures Stafford's place as a HOF QB. Stafford will win. But Allen is more valuable/clutch imo. I’d trade a 1st and Coleman for Mcvay to coach this team. Sean is great but Mcvay is a notch above. Quote
BillytheKid Posted December 19, 2025 Posted December 19, 2025 (edited) 1 hour ago, Buffalo Ballin said: Deserves? I disagree. Great stats. Still lost the game. If Rams enter playoffs as a Wild Card team, Stafford is no clear cut MVP. You can argue all you want. It’s no different than every Bills fan saying Allen played great against the Chiefs in the playoffs but he still lost. Wasn’t Allen’s fault he lost to the Chiefs. Or do you want to contradict yourself now? Cause that’s what you are doing. Im saying as of right now Stafford is MVP. Maybe in 3 weeks he won’t be. Edited December 19, 2025 by BillytheKid Quote
Kelly No huddle Posted December 19, 2025 Posted December 19, 2025 If Allen wins out and leads the NFL in tds It's going to be extremely difficult to not give him his 2nd MVP. It just is Quote
Special K Posted December 19, 2025 Author Posted December 19, 2025 2 hours ago, Process said: Well it's over, congrats to Stafford, a worthy MVP. Can't lose to Penix, Maye, Tua and Mills and be upset that another guy wins the award. Oops......premature coronation!! Nothing against Matt Stafford, but despite his fancy stats, Matt Stafford is no Josh Allen. Stafford can't run...I'd bet Josh could run faster than Stafford blindfolded after drinking 6 shots of Vodka!! If the Bills win out, and both the Rams and Bills are Wildcard teams, the MVP should hands down go to Josh. Quote
Buffalo Ballin Posted December 19, 2025 Posted December 19, 2025 5 minutes ago, BillytheKid said: You can argue all you want. It’s no different than every Bills fan saying Allen played great against the Chiefs in the playoffs but he still lost. Wasn’t Allen’s fault he lost to the Chiefs. Or do you want to contradict yourself now? Cause that’s what you are doing. Im saying as of right now Stafford is MVP. Maybe in 3 weeks he won’t be. ? I don't understand what you're trying to convey. As of right now, IN YOUR OPINION, Stafford is MVP. To me, Stafford is NOT the MVP. This race is not over. By the way, Josh Allen has the stats and narrative behind him. Stafford has stats, but no story. We'll see at the end of the regular season. But as of right now, there is no clear cut MVP front runner. Rams collapse and loss vs. Seattle really lowered Stafford's chances. Also, Rams could lose in Atlanta next Sunday. "If the Seahawks or 49ers win out, the Rams will be a wildcard team." - HappyDays If we lose at Cleveland Browns this Sunday, then yeah, Josh Allen's chances at league MVP are over. Quote
Dr.Sack Posted December 19, 2025 Posted December 19, 2025 Shakir > Puka Cook > Williams McDermott > McVay Beane > Snead Bills D > Rams D Bills are just better. Stafford is doing more with less. Allen has an ‘unfair’ advantage. 2 1 Quote
billieve420 Posted December 19, 2025 Posted December 19, 2025 19 minutes ago, Buffalo Ballin said: ? I don't understand what you're trying to convey. As of right now, IN YOUR OPINION, Stafford is MVP. To me, Stafford is NOT the MVP. This race is not over. By the way, Josh Allen has the stats and narrative behind him. Stafford has stats, but no story. We'll see at the end of the regular season. But as of right now, there is no clear cut MVP front runner. Rams collapse and loss vs. Seattle really lowered Stafford's chances. Also, Rams could lose in Atlanta next Sunday. "If the Seahawks or 49ers win out, the Rams will be a wildcard team." - HappyDays If we lose at Cleveland Browns this Sunday, then yeah, Josh Allen's chances at league MVP are over. No story? 37 yr old QB and Super Bowl winner with chance to lock first ballot HOF status with MVP award. That seems like a pretty good story to me. 2 Quote
Generic_Bills_Fan Posted December 19, 2025 Posted December 19, 2025 37 minutes ago, GoBills! said: I’d trade a 1st and Coleman for Mcvay to coach this team. Sean is great but Mcvay is a notch above. Coleman has 0 value y’all lol can’t believe he still comes up in trade discussions 😂 Quote
Buffalo Ballin Posted December 19, 2025 Posted December 19, 2025 13 minutes ago, billieve420 said: No story? 37 yr old QB and Super Bowl winner with chance to lock first ballot HOF status with MVP award. That seems like a pretty good story to me. Awful story. His age is the story?? What? The league MVP is not a lifetime achievement award. Super Bowl Winner? That's last season. What does that have to do with this season? Stafford is already a lock for HOF without the league MVP award. Let's face it, right now, there is no clear cut MVP front runner. There have been many NFL QBs who get spectacular stats, but don't get MVP. We'll see at the end of this season. We need to win out with Josh Allen getting good stats. Then after that? Let the Tetris blocks fall where they may. If we get the number 1 AFC spot? Watch out. Quote
GoBills! Posted December 19, 2025 Posted December 19, 2025 25 minutes ago, Generic_Bills_Fan said: Coleman has 0 value y’all lol can’t believe he still comes up in trade discussions 😂 He’s a rookie deal throw in. Just because I didn’t think we can afford 2 first and still do what’s need to win it all. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.