This roster is a disaster however…..

[Buffalo716]

1 minute ago, ganesh said:

It begs the question on what happened in Houston.  How did that OL allow 8 sacks on the reigning league MVP...Made his work so hard by running in circles in that stadium

Both our tackles playing hurt on a fast field in their dome.. 

 

A lot of 5 man protections 

 

But that's something our line can adjust to and game plan for better seeing it now if we have to go up against them again.. we'll see more six man protections and chips and block and releases 

[Flipnmi]

13 hours ago, GaryPinC said:

It's a difficulty, but good GMs find a way to ID those players and get it done.  He's had 8 drafts + McDermott in 2017.  

Please give me examples to support your blanket statement. Every GM including Beane, have had a few picks that outplay their draft position, but real game changing talent usually come out of the top 10 picks. 

Edited 1 hour ago by Flipnmi
Typo

[Shaw66]

1 hour ago, GaryPinC said:

That's great for building a strong regular season team and culture, but we need to draft guys willing to step up and be difference makers in the playoffs. That's where we are at and Beane has to make the drafting shift.  Seems like he's starting to tune into it with this year's draft, but he needed to shift 2-4 years ago.

 

WRT salary concerns, that even more favors the first contract salary discounts through drafting.

People say this, and I get the point, but when you're drafting 30th every year, who's a difference maker is a crap shoot. It's not so much a shift as it to be better at finding the right guys. Elam and now Coleman really hurt. You aren't likely to get a star at 30 or later, but you absolutely can't afford a bust/near bust.  Bishop looks like a winner, and Cook was. Kincaid hasn't had the impact people hoped. Beane needs to be better in the first and second round. 

 

He's never going to draft away from culture and team players. That's what McDermott wants. 

[Old Coot]

With this disaster of a roster, all the injuries and poor coaching. I'll bet we must be 4-9.

[GunnerBill]

4 hours ago, NewEra said:

And equally impressive that we still have a very good OL.  2 2nd rd picks, a 3rd rd, a higher mid tier FA to go with one of the best value OGs in Edwards.  Beane did a good job constructing it

 

On offensive line he inherited, from McDermott's draft, a franchise left tackle and that is the most important peice. The second most important peice (especially for a young Quarterback) is a center and after blowing it when Josh was a rookie with Russ Bodine and Ryan Groy (Beane's own words a "horrible job") he went out and paid what at the time was the biggest center deal in NFL history for Mitch Morse. 

 

He has spent a 2nd round pick (bust) and a 3rd round pick (hit) at right tackle and a 2nd round pick at guard. 

 

While McGovern and Edwards were great value FAs and they have built some good depth with clever scouting - I do think his level of investment on oline has been about right for a team with an established top 10/12 Left Tackle. If they every had to replace Dion then I think they would have  to consider using a 1st round pick... but my guess is that will be for the next regime to worry about in some shape or form. 

 

Compare that to WR where he all he inherited from McDermott's draft was Zay Jones. He traded a 1st and a 4th for Diggs and spent a 2nd on Keon Coleman and that is it in terms of early draft investments. After that he got great value in Gabe Davis (4th) and Shakir (5th) but hasn't allocated big assets. And it is not like he has spent big cap dollars either. Diggs is also the only receiver they have ever paid close to a top of the market deal to (the extension didn't work out as well as the trade, obviously). It is just mind boggling to me. If he is still in a job by March (I think he will be) it MUST be with an ultimatum from Pegula that by hook or by crook Josh Allen needs a #1 receiver on this team in 2026.