Is Cook the best RB right now?

[Nihilarian]

Number one in my book! 

[BuffaloBillyG]

5 hours ago, BillsPride12 said:

I have him at 3 behind Jayhmir Gibbs and Jonathan Taylor.

I have him clustered with those 2, Atlanta's Robinson, and Achane. I think the best can change from week to week. 

[Freddie's Dead]

Yes.  At his current contract, we robbed him blind.

[Niagara Dude]

6 hours ago, Billsfed1 said:

It’s close.

 

If he’s not 1, he’s 2 IMO.

 

Incredible talent, needs to be utilized more in the passing game.  Bring that about this winter and were going places in January.

I think if they used him like Thurman in passing game then he could best all round back. 

[Bockeye]

7 minutes ago, Niagara Dude said:

I think if they used him like Thurman in passing game then he could best all round back. 

Right!  Instead of that stupid screen pass to Shakir that fails 9 out of 10 times, how about some swing passes to Cook.

[Big Blitz]

Right now:  
 

Taylor

Gibbs 

Bijan 

Cook 

Achane 

 

Top 5

[wppete]

 

[BearNorth]

PFF lost a good deal of credibility this week.  Cook goes for 177 yards from scrimmage and they grade him in the low 50's.  Wonder what game they were watching?

[AKC]

1 hour ago, HamptonBillsfan said:

I love all of your 6 but Cook is the only one that looks like a threat to go all the way every time he gets to the 2nd level and also can get the edge with one cut and beat DBs around the corner with ease. Cook is a matchup nightmare in the passing game and if given the touches can be as prolific as CMC. Listen I’m an unapologetic homer, but between having a nose for the end zone and amassing 1500 yards if given the carries, Cook is #1 and we got him for as long as we can legally keep him. Last reason, he’s always available.

You have a lot of this right, and JC has elite short area quickness along with exceptional vision/instincts he has developed, but his Achilles in the pass game is catching over his shoulder. It looks like Brady is giving him pass catch opps where the ball comes into his chest, the way Detroit used Barry Sanders in their passing game. He would pretty easily be the most dangerous RB in the game if he was reliable grabbing it on the run in front of him, but to date that hasn’t been a choice in his quiver.

[HamptonBillsfan]

34 minutes ago, AKC said:

You have a lot of this right, and JC has elite short area quickness along with exceptional vision/instincts he has developed, but his Achilles in the pass game is catching over his shoulder. It looks like Brady is giving him pass catch opps where the ball comes into his chest, the way Detroit used Barry Sanders in their passing game. He would pretty easily be the most dangerous RB in the game if he was reliable grabbing it on the run in front of him, but to date that hasn’t been a choice in his quiver.

Haven’t considered that since he’s underused period in the passing game. Brady is not imaginative enough to take advantage of his awesome skills that could easily be the difference between having a substandard receiving corps and a back that must be accounted for in the passing game, making every receiver better.

[Ray Stonada]

This off season I wrote Cook was worth 15 million, and got ridiculed.

 

I think the guy is as good as anyone and a game changer. Use him like Thurman and we can dominate this postseason. 

Edited 3 hours ago by Ray Stonada
Fricking autocorrect

[Dillenger4]

16 hours ago, HamptonBillsfan said:

Top 5? Give me the other 4 after Taylor. Saquon got paid and is mostly a non-factor. The Eagles are offensively challenged because Barkley took a step back. McCaffrey is great but not the runner that Cook is. He’s terrific in the pass game but Cook would be also if given the touches. After that’s all of competition.

I just said top 5 because I quickly guessed. But here it goes:

Taylor

McCaffrey (Stud)

Gibbs (runs wayyy harder than Cook)

Cook

The Pats RB.

[HamptonBillsfan]

2 hours ago, Dillenger4 said:

I just said top 5 because I quickly guessed. But here it goes:

Taylor

McCaffrey (Stud)

Gibbs (runs wayyy harder than Cook)

Cook

The Pats RB.

The first year Cook is getting real carries he’s going to be 16 to 1800 yds. He had 16 TDs and over 1000 with only 200 carries last year and he’s always available. Our offense has been deigned around his ability. Gibbs shared carries with Montgomery and McCaffrey is great but he’s much older and lost 2 seasons with injury. The Pats RB is a rookie, enough said.