Franchise QB Options

[jwhit34]

Pick your franchise QB

[PetermansRedemption]

Homer alert, but give me Allen. Second choice was close between Murray, Burrow and Herbert. Went with Murray because he is slightly more proven at this point.

Edited October 22, 2020 by PetermansRedemption

[RyanC883]

went Allen/Burrow.  Burrow is really surprising.  

[ALLEN1QB]

Who picked the QB on IR as their QB? LMAO

[ny33]

I’d give the expansion team Mayfield, then Tua, so that Allen and the Bills could destroy them.  😛

[H2o]

Allen and went with Herbert 2nd, though I would be happy to flip a coin and take whichever QB fate handed between Burrow or Herbert. 

[Kwai San]

Also Allen/Burrow......although the way Burrow is playing.........if he keeps playing up like he is now?  WOW!

[CountDorkula]

Went with Herbert and Prescott.

 

People severely underrate Dak.

[ny33]

1 minute ago, CountDorkula said:

Went with Herbert and Prescott.

 

People severely underrate Dak.

Dak is the best on the list but would also take a huge chunk of the cap 

[Ethan in Cleveland]

I went with Josh Allen but ask this question again next year and it might be Burrow or Herbert.  For the record I thought Herbert was going to be a bust.  He padded his stats against patsies at Oregon with few great wins until his senior year Rose Bowl win.  I like Lamar and I think a team can win with him, but I worry about longevity.  

[Rc2catch]

I went with Allen, homer pick as well but nobody has his intangibles. 
Took Herbert second, kid is a star in the making and makes wow plays. I haven’t seen that from Burrow. And I don’t like Kyler 

[MJS]

2 minutes ago, Rc2catch said:

I went with Allen, homer pick as well but nobody has his intangibles. 
Took Herbert second, kid is a star in the making and makes wow plays. I haven’t seen that from Burrow. And I don’t like Kyler 

Exact same for me.

 

I don't want primarily a running QB. Allen can run but he also has a bazooka arm. Jackson and Murray are good, but I wouldn't choose them over guys like Allen and Herbert.

[BillsFan130]

1. Burrow

2. Allen 

[Rc2catch]

5 minutes ago, MJS said:

Exact same for me.

 

I don't want primarily a running QB. Allen can run but he also has a bazooka arm. Jackson and Murray are good, but I wouldn't choose them over guys like Allen and Herbert.

I didn’t like Herbert much, then I was like well Keenan Allen is awesome and makes him look good, but now the kid is just a baller like Allen. Makes all the throws, keeps plays alive, doesn’t seem to get panicked under pressure. And can throw to anyone on their team.  

[BillsDude]

Do not show this poll to Mayfield. He still has a chip on his shoulder and I want it to come off...

[Chicken Boo]

1) Kyler Murray

2) Joe Burrow

 

Is what I voted.  Looking back at the list, I'd be ok with any of them, outside of Mayfield.

[NewEra]

16 minutes ago, Ethan in Portland said:

I went with Josh Allen but ask this question again next year and it might be Burrow or Herbert.  For the record I thought Herbert was going to be a bust.  He padded his stats against patsies at Oregon with few great wins until his senior year Rose Bowl win.  I like Lamar and I think a team can win with him, but I worry about longevity.  

Are you a beaver, duck or neither?

[IgotBILLStopay]

1. JA

2. Justin Herbert - has looked very impressive so far.

 

Burrow is a close third with Jackson and Murray being 4 and 5. Jury still out on Tua, two NFL completions notwithstanding. Pass on Tannehill, Prescott and Mayfield.

 

funnily enough two different franchises moved on from Tyrod Taylor to get these top two franchise QBs

 

 

 

 

[Captain Hindsight]

Went with Josh and Herbert. Josh has two rough games, but I'm pretty confident he is going to bounce back. He just wants it so bad, ill take my chances with a guy like him

 

I considered Burrow over Herbert, but I think Herbert has already looked like a budding star. Burrow is getting there too. Either would be good

[TroutDog]

47 minutes ago, H2o said:

Allen and went with Herbert 2nd, though I would be happy to flip a coin and take whichever QB fate handed between Burrow or Herbert. 

I did the same. If there was more of a Tua track record, perhaps that would change for me. Being a Bama fan, I appreciate the kid.