Jump to content

Cordy Glenn at Odds With Bengals Over Concussion


H2o

Recommended Posts

6 hours ago, Seoulofstone said:

The trade up for Josh is looking pretty good with benefit of hindsight.

 

 

Too early to say, but it's been good for both sides.

 

My sympathies are usually with the injured person. They know better than doctors if they're still suffering symptoms. Glenn was a good teammate here. Concussions are serious business, and Cincy should back down a bit. A second opinion is a very very reasonable thing.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

43 minutes ago, Thurman#1 said:

 

 

Too early to say, but it's been good for both sides.

 

My sympathies are usually with the injured person. They know better than doctors if they're still suffering symptoms. Glenn was a good teammate here. Concussions are serious business, and Cincy should back down a bit. A second opinion is a very very reasonable thing.


a second is reasonable though worth noting it’s an independent doctor that clears concussion protocols. 

 

and neither side should delay the opinions

 

i tend to believe players about injuries, but they owe it to the team to seek timely diagnosis and treatment should the player claim an injury and not want to use team treatments 

Edited by NoSaint
Link to comment
Share on other sites

3 hours ago, NoSaint said:


what got them worst was giving big deals to two homegrown players that were out the door within about a year (graham and galette). Those bonus accelerations were hellacious. And on the heels of bountygate. and poor drafting. It was quite the time. Byrd was an issue but contributing to the problem not primary to it..

 

It sure was.  The other thing was how many restructured contracts they went thru to open up more cap space.

What NO went thru during those years was one of the main reason I got into understanding cap limits/contracts etc.

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

7 hours ago, Mr. WEO said:

Bradley Beale--maybe a top 25 player---just got 72 million for 2 years.   That's more than any player in the NFL makes.  All guaranteed.

The player's union have a lot more clout in the NBA since roster sizes are only about a fourth of the NFL and of those only about half play on a regular basis.  NBA players also last about a year and a half longer on average as it's not the physical sport football is.  Any kid going into college highly recruited in basketball and football should pry choose the former in most instances.  Same goes for picking baseball against football (unless you're out of this world talented like Russell Wilson and possibly Kyler Murray).

Link to comment
Share on other sites

14 hours ago, Hapless Bills Fan said:

 

Since "avoiding playing as much as possible" was arguably what Byrd did to the Bills (as long as he could while getting paid), the Saints had every reason to know what they were getting with Byrd. 

As the Al Wilson song says " "I saved you," cried the woman "And you've bitten me, but why? You know your bite is poisonous and now I'm going to die"
"Oh shut up, silly woman," said the reptile with a grin "You knew damn well I was a snake before you took me in"

 

 

I don't think that's fair at all, Hapless. In his first four years, Byrd played nearly every game. Every single game in year 3 and year 4. It was only in his fifth year, when tagged that he became careful. And why wouldn't you? When you have a foot injury in a contract year, would you play and put bad performances on film?

 

Byrd was a team guy, playing on the same injury in year 4. But when the Bills tagged him, it only made sense not to play at less than full strength. I'd have done the same, rehabbing as hard as I could but protecting myself.

 

The Saints got Byrd's best, as the Bills did the first four years, but he fit the Bills and didn't fit the Saints early and he hurt his back and was never the same after he got to N.O. And by the way, having Rob Ryan as your coordinator, as he did in the Big Easy, isn't the way to maximize your performance.

 

 

Edited by Thurman#1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

11 hours ago, unbillievable said:

 

Concussions are tricky because doctors have to rely on input from patients. There are the obvious symptoms, and then there are the "how do you feel, today?" diagnosis.

Glenn's "concussion" was self-reported, and fans have pointed out that they can't find the play where he got hurt. He wasn't presenting with any symptoms, and no one had a clue, until Cordy went to the doctors himself. 

 

The Bengals are basically accusing him of faking it, now; after 8 weeks.

 

 

Very similar to planters fakeitis Byrd had - it depends on input from patient.

 

I was diagnosed with it after seeing doctor who claimed he could find no physical issue and it was psychosomatic (found out later actually written on chart).

 

Went to another doctor and he thought it was planters and he put me in a hard boot to soften the foot and it almost crippled me.

He said that should not happened and ordered a MRI.  He found a cyst the size of a golf ball in my ankle and it was removed by specialist.

 

After I recovered I went to doctor who labelled it "in my head" and told receptionist I had trouble getting insurance to pay and I needed to see my file.

She pulled it out and gave it to me.  When I read it I started getting loud and 2 doctors and nurse came out of office with one being a doctor.

In front of staff and patients I called him a quack and he said he would sue me for slander and I told him to go ahead.

I started reading file"

  • Patient appears to be shopping around doctors, he reported 6 before office visit."  
  • "No physical issues, entirely psychosomatic."
  • etc

Then I dropped a copy of my CD with MRI on table.  Here is what a real doctor determined.  Doctor found a cyst in ankle intertwined between ankle bones, tendons and blood vessels.  Immediate surgery is necessary.

 

At this point a number of patients started leaving with one telling receptionist she was cancelling appointment.

 

Doctor demanded file and I refused stating I may need it in court.  I will get a notarized copy and return it; you may need to defend yourself to medical practices board. 

I checked and you had no credentials to diagnose a "mental illness".  Since I could not get insurance claim paid I will need to show this to insurance company.

Was never contacted by doctor except for a call asking for copy of file returned, doctor's office declined to attempt to attempt to get me to pay bill anymore.

 

 

Anytime a diagnosis is made requiring non-empirical data it is not science but guess work.  

With concussions you are dealing with the most complex organ in the body.

The NFL needs to protect itself especially with contracts guaranteed for injury but to prevent abuse there must be some contracted standard otherwise many players will act like Percy Harvin did go off rosters, get paid and then try to return and repeat when they fell well.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

13 hours ago, Scott7975 said:

I don't understand why anyone would want to re-sign a player that has obviously gotten paid and mailed it in.  The dude is lazy.  Bean got rid of him for a reason.  People want him back.  sigh.

 

 

Beane did get rid of him for a reason. That reason seems to have been to get Josh Allen or another one of the top QBs that year.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Cordy just doesn’t want to be there. He sees a total rebuild and he has been there done that with us. Next he’ll be making Trent Williams like trade demands. The problem is he just isn't as good as his big paycheck. I liked him when he was here, but I’m pretty happy he’s gone now. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

15 hours ago, Utah John said:

By avoiding playing as much as possible.  Check out news stories about him and the Saints.  They describe his signing as a complete disaster for their organization.

It was a disaster signing because he was injured.

2 hours ago, Limeaid said:

 

 

Very similar to planters fakeitis Byrd had - it depends on input from patient.

 

I was diagnosed with it after seeing doctor who claimed he could find no physical issue and it was psychosomatic (found out later actually written on chart).

 

Went to another doctor and he thought it was planters and he put me in a hard boot to soften the foot and it almost crippled me.

He said that should not happened and ordered a MRI.  He found a cyst the size of a golf ball in my ankle and it was removed by specialist.

 

After I recovered I went to doctor who labelled it "in my head" and told receptionist I had trouble getting insurance to pay and I needed to see my file.

She pulled it out and gave it to me.  When I read it I started getting loud and 2 doctors and nurse came out of office with one being a doctor.

In front of staff and patients I called him a quack and he said he would sue me for slander and I told him to go ahead.

I started reading file"

  • Patient appears to be shopping around doctors, he reported 6 before office visit."  
  • "No physical issues, entirely psychosomatic."
  • etc

Then I dropped a copy of my CD with MRI on table.  Here is what a real doctor determined.  Doctor found a cyst in ankle intertwined between ankle bones, tendons and blood vessels.  Immediate surgery is necessary.

 

At this point a number of patients started leaving with one telling receptionist she was cancelling appointment.

 

Doctor demanded file and I refused stating I may need it in court.  I will get a notarized copy and return it; you may need to defend yourself to medical practices board. 

I checked and you had no credentials to diagnose a "mental illness".  Since I could not get insurance claim paid I will need to show this to insurance company.

Was never contacted by doctor except for a call asking for copy of file returned, doctor's office declined to attempt to attempt to get me to pay bill anymore.

 

 

Anytime a diagnosis is made requiring non-empirical data it is not science but guess work.  

With concussions you are dealing with the most complex organ in the body.

The NFL needs to protect itself especially with contracts guaranteed for injury but to prevent abuse there must be some contracted standard otherwise many players will act like Percy Harvin did go off rosters, get paid and then try to return and repeat when they fell well.

Medical practices board lol

Link to comment
Share on other sites

20 hours ago, H2o said:

https://profootballtalk.nbcsports.com/2019/10/17/bengals-cordy-glenn-at-odds-over-handling-of-his-concussion/

 

 

If I am not mistaken, wasn't he at odds with the Bills as well over his foot injury while here? Either way, they are likely headed for a divorce one way or another most likely. 

 

I would bring him back if healthy on a Vet Min and put him at the RT spot

Hmmm I find it funny that the same people that are saying I would never take him back because he doesnt want to risk Brain (having lingering symptoms) are the the same People that would trade for AJ Green who is milking his Injury to not play for the train wreck in Cincy

17 hours ago, Albany,n.y. said:

Why does anyone want him back?  In the NFL the most important ability is availability and while Glenn has some ability it's to no avail.  

Let me guess would you trade for AJ Green?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

19 minutes ago, MAJBobby said:

 

I would bring him back if healthy on a Vet Min and put him at the RT spot

Hmmm I find it funny that the same people that are saying I would never take him back because he doesnt want to risk Brain (having lingering symptoms) are the the same People that would trade for AJ Green who is milking his Injury to not play for the train wreck in Cincy

Let me guess would you trade for AJ Green?

Why would anyone want AJ Green at the Shawne Merriman point of his career?  

Edited by Albany,n.y.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Just now, Albany,n.y. said:

Why would anyone want AJ Green at the Shawne Merriman point of his career?  

 

No Idea but there is a Huge Bills fan contingent that wants to trade for Green

Well this will make that Relationship even worse.

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

×
×
  • Create New...