Jump to content

Do you think Robert Foster can develop to into a #1 receiver?


BBills88

Recommended Posts

35 minutes ago, Teddy KGB said:

No.     Move him to cornerback asap 

 

That would require him being able to track a ball though

 

34 minutes ago, oldmanfan said:

The kid gets open, have to give him that.  But if he doesn't star tfinishing plays there's no place in the league for him.  Receivers have to, you know, receive.

 

Blasphemy 

They only need to get open.

Catching the ball?

Nobody got time for that.

 

7 minutes ago, Cripple Creek said:

He does seem to be able to get open.

 

That's because the other team doesn't bother covering somebody who can't catch.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

21 minutes ago, dorquemada said:

Lots of trite answers in this thread based (mostly fairly) on Foster's play thus far.  Most people thought Jason Peters would never be any good either.  I'm willing to give the coaches the benefit of the doubt on this one and see if he can develop.  If he's a late bloomer and turns into even a solid #2 then it's a huge steal for the Bills.  If he never develops the skills, then they move on. It's not like his reps are coming at the expense of Andre Reed sitting on the bench.

 

 

Yup.  Daboll obviously has seen something we don't.

I don’t know. Some projected Jason Peters as high as the second round. He just didn’t have a position. He was a college TE that was the size of a tackle. He was very, very raw coming out but had a chance to be special based on his physical skills. Mike Jasper was the same way. I use him so that it doesn’t look like revisionist history. Sometimes elite physical traits translate and sometimes they don’t.

 

Foster is a former 5-star that never lived up to his status at ‘Bama. He was an afterthought and a part-time player. He was a disappointment in his time there from what they expected. Hopes of him becoming a number 1 aren’t at all realistic. We should hope that he learns to track (and catch) the deep ball. If he can develop into a 3 or 4 that can stretch the field he can be a useful player going forward. That’s a ball that Allen is always going to throw. If he can run underneath a few he can be an asset. 

  • Like (+1) 4
Link to comment
Share on other sites

50 minutes ago, BBills88 said:

They are allowing their young players to develop through live experience, with that being said would it be possible the staff is trying to allow Robert Foster to get the necessary experience to become the number 1 receiver? It happened for a few players throughout the years.

 

What are your thoughts?

 

 

This is about as likely as me developing into a #1 receiver.  It’s not going to happen.

  • Like (+1) 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, BBills88 said:

They are allowing their young players to develop through live experience, with that being said would it be possible the staff is trying to allow Robert Foster to get the necessary experience to become the number 1 receiver? It happened for a few players throughout the years.

 

What are your thoughts?

 

Name those few players.

 

They had to have shown the same tendencies as Robert Foster: has trouble bringing the ball in and relies on the go route as the primary means of getting open.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

14 minutes ago, Kirby Jackson said:

Foster is a former 5-star that never lived up to his status at ‘Bama. He was an afterthought and a part-time player. He was a disappointment in his time there from what they expected. Hopes of him becoming a number 1 aren’t at all realistic. We should hope that he learns to track (and catch) the deep ball. If he can develop into a 3 or 4 that can stretch the field he can be a useful player going forward. That’s a ball that Allen is always going to throw. If he can run underneath a few he can be an asset. 

 

Obviously the answer to the question is no.  I agree with you Kirby that he hasn't even proved he is an NFL level #4 on the worst WR group in the league. Let alone more than that. However, I wouldn't cut him this year now the way this team is designed. Throwing deep to him 3 or so times a game seems part of their plan to open other stuff up. He is averaging about 1 catch in 6 so far.... (not all on him some of the balls haven't been accurate) but even at that ratio teams kind of have to account for it because it looks like the Bills are going to stick with that plan. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Maybe if the Bills paid for an operation to remove those Tyrannosaurus Rex arms he displayed on that deep ball along the sideline on Sunday, and replaced them with human arms...

 

….any human arms at all, from infant to old age. Couldn't be worse...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

No.  Sign Brandon Reilly.  He will catch the ball.  In fact - given that not one poster in this thread has said "yes" is pretty damn good evidence Reilly should have been kept on the 53 to begin with - no need for Foster (or Kerley).  Would have been far better of with Reilly and Streater - but Streater now gone.  SIGN REILLY!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, BBills88 said:

They are allowing their young players to develop through live experience, with that being said would it be possible the staff is trying to allow Robert Foster to get the necessary experience to become the number 1 receiver? It happened for a few players throughout the years.

 

What are your thoughts?

 

I think he should join the Olympic running team,just don't put him in the relay ;)

 

Did this kid forget to pack his hands when he left Alabama?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, Kirby Jackson said:

I don’t know. Some projected Jason Peters as high as the second round. He just didn’t have a position. He was a college TE that was the size of a tackle. He was very, very raw coming out but had a chance to be special based on his physical skills. Mike Jasper was the same way. I use him so that it doesn’t look like revisionist history. Sometimes elite physical traits translate and sometimes they don’t.

 

Foster is a former 5-star that never lived up to his status at ‘Bama. He was an afterthought and a part-time player. He was a disappointment in his time there from what they expected. Hopes of him becoming a number 1 aren’t at all realistic. We should hope that he learns to track (and catch) the deep ball. If he can develop into a 3 or 4 that can stretch the field he can be a useful player going forward. That’s a ball that Allen is always going to throw. If he can run underneath a few he can be an asset.

You make a terrific point that the type of long pass that Allen throws is his hallmark talent. The emphasis should be on getting a receiver who would accentuate the qb's special talent. What everyone can see (except for Sky Diver the Bama zealot) is that Foster is not going to fit that role.

 

Foster certainly can get open for the long ball. But there is a reason for that beyond his exceptional speed: He is not going to be double covered because of his lack of production related to his catching skills. The Bills are still in the rebuilding mode. There are a lot of needs that still need to be addressed. Certainly, one of the items on the multiple checklist is addressing the receiver unit. 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

×
×
  • Create New...