The Bills continued to cement their status as “Not Ready For Prime Time Players” with their ninth consecutive loss under the lights. (Of course, another game was added to that streak last month.) How long has it been since their last primetime win? Check the name of the quarterback:
Primetime games since 2000:
Date
Score
Bills Starting QB
Sunday, Sept. 3, 2000
Bills 16, Titans 13
Rob Johnson
Monday, Dec. 11, 2000
Colts 44, Bills 20
Rob Johnson
Saturday, Dec. 23, 2000
Bills 42, Seahawks 23
Doug Flutie
Thursday, Oct. 18, 2001
Bills 13, Jaguars 10
Rob Johnson
Sunday, Dec. 2, 2001
49ers 35, Bills 0
Alex Van Pelt
Sunday, Sept. 21, 2003
Dolphins 17, Bills 7
Drew Bledsoe
Sunday, Oct. 26, 2003
Chiefs 38, Bills 5
Drew Bledsoe
Sunday, Nov. 14, 2004
Patriots 29, Bills 6
Drew Bledsoe
Sunday, Oct. 30, 2005
Patriots 21, Bills 16
Kelly Holcomb
Saturday, Dec. 17, 2005
Broncos 28, Bills 17
Kelly Holcomb
Sunday, Sept. 21, 2007
Cowboys 25, Bills 24
Trent Edwards
Saturday, Dec. 17, 2007
Patriots 56, Bills 10
J.P. Losman
Monday, Nov. 17, 2008
Browns 29, Bills 27
Trent Edwards
Monday, Sept. 14, 2009
Patriots 25, Bills 24
Trent Edwards
Come-from-ahead heartbreakers, blowouts, they’re all in there. Early on, this game looked like it would end up in the latter category: Trent Edwards started the game with an interception on the Bills’ first offensive play and added two more before the end of the first quarter, then spent most of the rest of the night trying to regain his confidence with dumpoffs to Marshawn Lynch, who ended the night with 10 receptions while Lee Evans was shut out for the first time in 68 games. Fortunately for Buffalo, the 3-6 Browns were unable to muster more than six points from Edwards’ early Christmas presents, and Rian Lindell’s 26-yard field goal at the gun sent them into the locker room trailing just 13-10.
The teams swapped three-pointers in the third quarter, before Browns running back Jerome Harrison stunned both the defense and the Ralph Wilson Stadium crowd with a 72-yard sprint to the end zone that appeared to salt the win away for Cleveland. Not even close. Leodis McKelvin took the ensuing kickoff 98 yards for the second touchdown in 27 seconds, and the Bills were back in the game. Following Phil Dawson’s fourth field goal and a pair of punts, the Bills offense took the field trailing 26-20 with just over five minutes left. Lynch broke free for a long run down to the 1, Edwards capped off the drive with a sneak on the next play, and remarkably, the Bills took their first lead of the game with 2:35 remaining.
However, that merely set the stage for Dawson’s heroics. The Browns quickly moved to the Bills 39, but three straight Brady Quinn incompletions brought the veteran kicker on for his fifth attempt of the night. Some Bills fans began to celebrate, thinking that the 56-yarder was outside his range. No such luck, and the Browns retook the lead.
The Bills still had a shot, though. Cleveland decided to kick away from McKelvin, but Fred Jackson alertly snared Dawson’s pop-up and returned it to the 44, and with 1:33 and a timeout left, there was plenty of time to move into range to give Lindell a shot at winning it. Edwards started the drive by rifling a 22-yard strike to Robert Royal, setting up a first down at the Browns 34.
And then, someone on the Bills sideline decided they’d gone far enough, that even with the below-freezing temperatures and the nine-mph headwind, they were content with letting Lindell try one from long range. Three consecutive Lynch dives into the middle of the line netted five yards, the 47-yarder sailed wide, and two Quinn kneeldowns ended the game.
(Aside: I won’t repeat the words I used in Section 237 that night, as soon as I saw Lynch take the handoff on first down. But you can safely assume that it was a profane variation of, “You’re kidding me,” followed by, “Hope you make this, Rian.”)